The Pittsburgh Steelers have the option to strengthen their quarterback depth just days before the 2025 NFL season kicks off. Aaron Rodgers, who arrived in Pittsburgh this offseason, is set to start under center for Mike Tomlin, although the situation behind him remains uncertain. Mason Rudolph, rookie Will Howard, and Skylar Thompson make up the depth chart, but injuries and inconsistency have left the coaching staff concerned, heading into Week 1.
Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Steelers rookie QB Will Howard during 2025 training camp in Latrobe, PA.
Howard, a sixth-round pick, suffered a broken finger during training camp and will probably begin the year on injured reserve. As a result, Rudolph and Thompson will serve as the primary backups. While both players have shown potential, neither is considered a long-term solution, prompting the team to consider outside options.
Some reports have linked the Steelers to Anthony Richardson, currently the backup quarterback for the Indianapolis Colts, behind Daniel Jones. Richardson was once considered one of the most exciting young talents in the league. Unfortunately, he has struggled with several injuries and inconsistent performances since being drafted fourth overall in 2023. So, a fresh start in Pittsburgh, with the chance to learn from Rodgers, could give him a chance to reset his career.
Analysts and even sports betting sites have started speculating about the potential move, suggesting that a quarterback trade could reshape Pittsburgh's outlook and long-term plans. Sportsbooks, which set the betting lines and odds for the upcoming games, have already adjusted the Steelers’ playoff chances to reflect the uncertainty at quarterback. NBC analyst Sanjesh Singh also pointed to the Steelers as a strong fit for Richardson, noting Rodgers’ age and the importance of finding a long-term successor.
While many expect Rodgers, 41, to retire at the end of this season, no official announcement has been made. The team’s approach to the quarterback room will probably reflect both their immediate ambitions and long-term strategy.
Adding a player like Richardson would provide valuable insurance this year, while establishing a succession plan for the seasons in the near future. With Rodgers leading the offense in 2025, Richardson could sit behind the veteran, gain more experience in the Steelers’ system, and learn from one of the league’s most accomplished quarterbacks. By 2026, he could be ready to step in as the starter, ensuring a smoother transition.
From the Steelers’ perspective, this move could also ease pressure in the upcoming draft. Instead of spending high picks on a quarterback, they could focus on other needs, such as offensive line, secondary, or wide receiver depth. Pittsburgh’s front office has long been known for balancing immediate competitiveness with future stability, and adding a young quarterback now fits that approach.
ESPN
Indianapolis Colts QB Anthony Richardson.
For Richardson, moving to Pittsburgh brings various benefits. He has the physical tools and athleticism to succeed, but has lacked stability and guidance early in his career. In Pittsburgh, he would gain both, without the pressure of being rushed into a starting role.
Spending a season behind Rodgers would allow him to learn how to read defenses, improve his decision-making, and adjust to a pro-style offense. This experience could accelerate his growth and prepare him to take over as the Steelers’ starter in 2026, making a great transition once Rodgers steps aside.
However, the timing of the reports underscores the urgency of the situation. As the regular season approaches, the Steelers are weighing the risks and benefits of making a move now rather than waiting for the next draft.
Rodgers’ presence brings instant credibility and excitement to Pittsburgh, but his age and the uncertainty behind him create a challenge for the coaching staff. A potential trade for Richardson, or another young quarterback in a similar situation, would demonstrate the team’s commitment to winning now and planning for the future.
The rumors around a possible trade also show the strategic thinking within the Steelers’ front office. In today’s NFL, where quarterback stability can make or break a team, Pittsburgh’s willingness to explore options shows a proactive approach to roster management.
While Rodgers remains the team’s centerpiece, the addition of a young, high-potential quarterback could provide insurance, depth, and a clear succession path. This will give the team flexibility as they compete in a highly competitive AFC North.
Finding a balance between short-term goals and long-term planning has always been a hallmark of the Steelers’ approach, and the quarterback situation is an example of that philosophy in action.
