As the Pittsburgh Steelers move deeper into the 2025 offseason, all eyes are on franchise cornerstone TJ Watt and the looming question: Will he retire a Steeler one day? It’s a storyline that’s quietly brewing beneath contract talks and roster reshuffling—one that gained traction after a recent appearance from Charlie Batch, former Steelers quarterback and Super Bowl XL champion.
Steelers.com
Former Steelers backup quarterback Charlie Batch became one of the most well-liked players in team history, as he finished the last eight years of his career with the team.
Batch didn’t sugarcoat the situation. While on the Up & Adams Show, he offered a brutally honest take that cuts to the heart of what fans have to realize as negotiations continue. When asked about Watt being a one-helmet play, Batch was transparent.
"That's tough to say, because I don't know how long he wants to play," Batch said. "Typically, you sign a four-year deal and then let's see what happens later on in his career. He needs to get closer to that Super Bowl, if not, winning that Super Bowl, for him to be convinced that he wants to stay here. He wants to be a one-helmet guy. Cam Heyward showed him how that works. But, ultimately, the goal in Pittsburgh is not to win division titles; it's to win a Super Bowl. So, he's going to pay attention to how the roster is made up.
It’s a sobering but realistic viewpoint from someone who’s been through it in the black and gold. While Watt has expressed admiration for long‑time teammates like Cameron Heyward, the notion of being a “one‑helmet guy” in today’s NFL is becoming difficult, and harder to pull off without championship validation.
"That's the business of football; when you look back, no matter how great you are, there's a strong chance the team that you start with, you're not going to finish with, right," Batch noted.
Watt’s legacy is on the clock. Batch’s comments come when the Steelers’ competitive window is being heavily scrutinized. The defense remains elite, and Watt continues to perform at a Defensive Player of the Year level, but for how long can that be sustained without a serious Super Bowl push?
Batch’s implication is clear. Watt’s loyalty has limits, and those limits are tethered to how serious the franchise is about contending. His commitment must be reciprocated with championship aspirations.
Barry Reeger / Imagn Images
In recent years, fans have seen plenty of examples around the league where elite players chase titles rather than staying in middling situations. Von Miller and JJ Watt are recent examples of this.
TJ Watt is not immune to those thoughts, and Batch didn’t shy away from admitting as much. Steelers’ Super Bowl standard remains the bar. Batch reminded fans (and maybe even the front office) what the standard is in Pittsburgh.
"Ultimately, the goal in Pittsburgh is not to win division titles — it's to win a Super Bowl."
That quote stings, especially in the context of recent seasons where the Steelers have hovered just outside serious contention. A Wild Card berth or 10-win season won’t be enough to convince someone like TJ Watt to spend the rest of his prime tied to a franchise that’s not going all‑in.
This isn’t just about money or personal accolades. Watt has already accomplished almost everything an edge rusher can individually. It’s about legacy, and whether that legacy can be fulfilled without hoisting a Lombardi Trophy remains to be seen.
Gene J. Puskar / AP
Steelers’ Defense Is Elite, But Is It Enough?
While much of the attention this offseason has been placed on the quarterback carousel and offensive question marks, the Steelers’ defense is arguably championship-ready. But as Batch warned, the future isn’t guaranteed. Hence when he stated: "no matter how great you are, there's a strong chance the team that you start with, you're not going to finish with, right?"
Few fans can picture TJ Watt in anything other than black and gold, but the NFL is a business, and sentiment doesn’t win championships. It’s clear from Batch’s tone signals that TJ Watt will pay close attention to how the roster evolves. The players probably know it, too.
The coaches know it. The front office has no margin for error. If the Steelers want to keep TJ Watt long‑term, they must not only make the playoffs, but they must look like legitimate threats to win it all. Anything less, and the conversation about TJ Watt’s future will only grow louder.
Do you think TJ Watt will retire in Pittsburgh? Let us know in the comments!
#SteelerNation
