Pre-game warmups should be routine. A few passes. Some light stretches. Nothing eventful. But for the Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 9, even warmups became a source of anxiety. Aaron Rodgers flexed his right hand on the field before their matchup against the Indianapolis Colts, and it immediately raised concern on the sidelines and in the stands.

Jared Wickerham / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' Aaron Rodgers warms up prior to a matchup with the Indianapolis Colts at home during the 2025 season.
This kind of moment matters more than you might think. Injury news travels fast in today’s sports landscape, and fans, as well as those who place bets, check their phones constantly before kick-off, scouring injury reports and social media for any updates. After all, one twisted ankle or even the most seemingly minor injury can shift betting lines in seconds.
This is why platforms tracking these developments have such important tools for anyone following the action closely. Resources like www.cardplayer.com’s california sportsbooks list fit into that bigger picture, since fans across the country often have to sort through different state rules and odds that shift from place to place while keeping an eye on how injury news can flip things fast.
Moments like the Steelers’ pre-game scare show how quickly everything can change. As reported by Sports Illustrated, the Colts entered Week 9 as 3.5-point favorites, with Pittsburgh at +145 on the moneyline and the total set at 50.5; numbers that can wobble in seconds when a player looks hurt during warmups. Fast, reliable info can shape expectations, decisions, and the odds that follow.
Pittsburgh has dealt with a steady stream of injury concerns this season, and Rodgers’ discomfort during warmups only added to the growing list. His repeated focus on his right leg made it clear that something was off. Given his ongoing injury challenges throughout the year, the moment created immediate uncertainty for the team.
Tony Romo immediately picked up on the problem from the broadcast booth, as he does know a thing or two about injury scares, having lived through many of them himself. He started to throw around theories on-air that a botched snap could have caused the problem, and wouldn’t be surprised if Aaron Rodgers sprained his hand grabbing a snap from the backup center.
Romo laid out to his viewers how these kinds of snaps matter. Because if the timing is off, the placement of the hand can be completely different, and one slight change can cause a finger to get smashed into the ground. Backup centers are notoriously problematic, too, compared to regular ones, and can throw off the rhythm between the quarterback and the center, as even just one terrible snap can cause serious damage. Even people who are good at what they do can get caught off guard.
As it turned out, Tony Romo was spot on in his analysis. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Ray Fittipaldo confirmed the circumstances. Rodgers jammed his finger on a pre-game warm-up snap with starting center Zach Frazier, not the backup, who gave him the snap, and Rodgers took it under the center, jamming his finger on the contact.
Fittipaldo captured the moment of Rodgers slamming the ball down on the grass after the snap, and described how his frustration was evident, and that he massaged his fingers before he took the next snap.
Happily, the injury was not too severe, and Rodgers was not ruled out of the Week 9 game against the Indianapolis Colts and took the field at the beginning of the first quarter as planned, averting a potential disaster. Losing Rodgers before this particular game would have hurt badly.
Going into this game without Rodgers would’ve been a blow to the Steelers, who were facing a strong Colts team with a lot of momentum. The Steelers desperately needed all their offensive firepower. Rodgers, who has been having a stunning season, has thrown for 1,489 yards and 16 touchdowns against just 5 interceptions. Even in losses, he stays on top of his game, and his consistency keeps the Steelers competitive.
Steelers' Rodgers Suffers Another Injury Versus Bengals
A loss of a quarterback like Rodgers, who is at the heart of the Steelers’ game plan, is basically guaranteed to cause problems because entire offenses are built around him, and the way he moves, plays to his strengths, and has a knack for timing routes all have to change when he’s out. You simply can’t plug in a replacement and expect the same results.
The Steelers were fortunate to avoid the worst-case scenario, but the real challenge starts now, with their backup situation in a tight spot. Mason Rudolph remains their first available option at the position, as he actually started in Week 12 versus the Chicago Bears. Rodgers suffered another more significant injury to his left wrist in a game against the Cincinnati Bengals which forced him to miss Sunday's action. Will Howard was recently activated back to the 53-man roster after being placed on injured reserve, though he's listed initially as the emergency third quarterback. Meanwhile, the team has parted ways with Logan Woodside, releasing him from the practice squad, and Skylar Thompson is sidelined with a hamstring injury.

Alysa Rubin / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' Aaron Rodgers throws with the other quarterbacks during mandatory minicamp in 2025.
So, Pittsburgh takes on Buffalo next with serious questions about depth. Their offense looks strong when healthy. But one more setback could change everything fast. Teams can scramble when quarterbacks drop. Game plans get rewritten overnight. Confidence takes a hit.
This whole situation highlights something important. Pre-game warmups are not just theater. They serve a real purpose. Players test their bodies. They check for problems before the game counts. Sometimes they discover issues in time to address them. Other times, they create new ones accidentally.
After injuries piled up, the Steelers learned, the hard way, that roster depth matters. Questions about the future quarterback continue to swirl around the organization. Keeping Rodgers healthy is not just important. It is essential for keeping their playoff hopes alive. Every snap matters now. Every warmup carries risk. The margin for error gets smaller as the season progresses.
Looking ahead, Pittsburgh faces challenging matchups that will test its roster strength. Their success hinges on maintaining health across key positions. The coaching staff knows they must balance risk with preparation during practice sessions.


