The Pittsburgh Steelers have a big investment in TJ Watt, and naturally, that is going to invite questions about his performance versus that investment. For the 2026 season, Watt carries a $32 million cash payout and a $42 million salary cap charge, according to Over The Cap. Those figures come with expectations that go beyond being a respected presence in the locker room. The Steelers need him to change games, especially against a dangerous divisional opponent.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Steelers edge rusher TJ Watt stands on the field as he enjoys a veteran day off while the team works out during a 2025 training camp practice at St. Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
Sunday night's 38-18 loss to the Cincinnati Bengals produced a particularly uncomfortable number in that discussion. Amarius Mims once again kept Watt from generating pressure in their direct matchups. It was a repeat of what happened earlier this season, with one important difference. This time, Mims received far less chip-block assistance.
Next Gen Stats shared the breakdown after the game, putting a measurable result behind a frustrating night for the defense. The tracking focused specifically on snaps involving Mims and Watt. That distinction matters, but it does not make the matchup result any easier for Steelers fans to accept.
"Amarius Mims did not allow a single pressure on 23 pass blocks against T.J. Watt in Week 10," Next Gen Stats posted. "Mims has now held Watt without pressure on 45 pass blocks this season."
The 45 opportunities across two games without a pressure allowed in is a difficult number to explain. Nobody should expect Watt to win every snap against an NFL tackle. However, the Steelers are paying for a defender capable of creating problems even against quality opposition. Mims has prevented that pressure production in both meetings this season.
The additional context makes the second performance more concerning. In the first matchup, the Bengals chipped Watt on eight of his 22 matchups with Mims. A chip gives the primary blocker additional assistance, often through a brief strike from another offensive player before that player continues his assignment. That help can disrupt a rusher's timing and path to the quarterback.

Karl Roser / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers linebacker TJ Watt is performing a pregame ritual with the linebackers prior to the Week 8 matchup against the Browns in November 2026.
On Sunday, the assistance was much less frequent. Mims still produced the same pressure-free result against Watt. That makes it harder to attribute this particular outcome simply to the Bengals consistently sending another player to help their tackle. The numbers show that explanation does not cover most of these matchups.
"Mims received chip block help just twice against Watt tonight," Next Gen Stats added. "Week 3: 8 of 22 matchups."
That is the detail the Steelers need to examine closely. A defender can influence an offense by demanding extra protection, even when he does not record a sack. In these tracked matchups, however, Mims needed chip help on only two snaps Sunday night. The Bengals were able to devote that help elsewhere or release those eligible receivers into their routes more often.
Steelers Need More From TJ Watt After Brutal Bengals Matchup
The contract figures should be discussed accurately. Watt's $42 million cap charge is not the same thing as his $32 million cash payout this season. Neither number means he alone is responsible for stopping an entire offense. They do explain why his individual results receive more scrutiny than those of a rotational defender with a smaller role.
There is also a limit to what the statistic establishes. It does not describe every Watt pass rush against every Bengals blocker, and it does not evaluate his run defense. Pressure can also depend on how quickly the ball leaves the quarterback's hand.
Still, those considerations should lead to a closer review, not an automatic dismissal of a troubling matchup. The review should identify which moves stalled and whether different alignments could have created better opportunities to affect the quarterback.
What concerns you most about this matchup and Watt's production relative to the investment? Share your Pittsburgh Steelers thoughts with @anthonyghalkias on X, and follow for more coverage and discussion. Many Steelers fans would say the numbers deserve an honest conversation after this loss.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

