The Pittsburgh Steelers have invested heavily in their offensive line, but one important question remains unanswered. Troy Fautanu needs to prove he can handle left tackle consistently. His transition has produced difficult moments, and the team cannot afford to keep wondering whether its quarterback will have enough time to operate. With the second half of the season underway, the young lineman has more at stake than simply putting together a better performance moving forward.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Steelers' offensive lineman Troy Fautanu stands on the playing surface as the team warms up on the field prior to a 2025 training camp practice being held at St. Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
Fautanu’s situation becomes more complicated when considering what is happening on the opposite side. Max Iheanachor has played well at right tackle, giving the coaching staff a reason to keep the rookie there long-term. Moving Fautanu back across the formation would disrupt a position that is providing encouraging results. That makes his development on the left side especially important.
There is still time for Fautanu to settle in. Playing left tackle requires consistency against defenders who can win with speed, power, or both. However, patience becomes harder to maintain when protection breakdowns affect the entire offense. His recent struggles have brought renewed attention to whether he can become the dependable starter the front office envisioned when he was drafted in the first round.
On the latest episode of the Steelers Collective, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette beat writer Ray Fittipaldo discussed Fautanu’s difficult outing. One particular sequence involving when Mason Rudolph came in for Aaron Rodgers illustrated how quickly a bad snap can turn into a bigger problem.
"The Fautanu thing, guys, like, you saw him get bull rushed into, into Mason [Rudolph]. He probably feels awful about that. Um, he gave up a sack after that. I mean, I don't know," Fittipaldo said.
Getting driven backward into the quarterback is not a very good sign for any lineman. Fittipaldo was closely watching Fautanu, and his performance late in Sunday night's loss was far from inspiring. That's a pretty big issue for the Steelers to focus on.
The discussion also touched on another potential position. However, the insider described Fautanu as having little interest in a move inside, while acknowledging that his current transition still deserves time.
"They're not going to do anything this year, but we asked Troy about, 'Hey, you know, do you think you'll ever play guard?' He was like, 'No.' Because he wants to get, he wants to get paid like a left tackle. I don't blame him, but this transition, um, You gotta give it more than a half a year. But it's not going swimmingly right now at left tackle for Troy."
There is nothing wrong with Fautanu wanting to establish himself at a premium position. That ambition must eventually be supported by reliable play, though. The offense needs protection it can trust, especially when obvious passing situations allow opposing rushers to attack without hesitation.
Iheanachor’s success makes that responsibility harder to escape. Right tackle is occupied by a young player who is giving the team reasons for optimism. Reversing those roles would require a compelling football reason, and Fautanu’s discomfort alone should not outweigh what Iheanachor is accomplishing.

Karl Roser / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' Troy Fautanu blocks against a pass rush during a road loss to the Patriots in 2026.
The upcoming contract decision adds another layer. Fautanu’s fifth-year option would cover the 2028 campaign, with the decision coming during the 2027 offseason. Ideally, picking it up should be straightforward for a first-round investment developing into a trusted starter. His inconsistency at left tackle could make that conversation considerably more difficult.
That does not mean the Steelers should already decide against the option. It means the remaining games carry real weight. The front office needs evidence that Fautanu can correct recurring problems and sustain those improvements against different opponents.
Steelers Need Fautanu To Finish The 2026 Season Strong
The back half of the season gives Fautanu an opportunity to change the conversation. He does not need to become flawless overnight. He needs to show that his technique, confidence, and response to adversity are moving in the right direction.
Strong performances would help establish trust before an important offseason decision. More uneven outings would leave the front office weighing the cost of commitment against uncertainty at a critical position. With Iheanachor playing well on the right, Fautanu’s clearest path forward is making left tackle his own. The remaining schedule will reveal how close he is to doing that.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

