Mike Tomlin Exposed By Former Player For Coaching Tactics That Ruined A Steelers Season

The Pittsburgh Steelers have been one of the most consistent franchises in all of American sports, but that consistency took a hit after the 2025 season came to a close as former head coach Mike Tomlin stepped down from his role. He was replaced by Mike McCarthy, but there is a little bit of optimism surrounding him and his new coaching staff at this stage of the offseason. It will be interesting to see how things pan out, but it has also been interesting to hear former players come out and talk about Tomlin as a head coach. As expected, most of the stories have been extremely positive, but some have painted the coach in a bad light.

Since Tomlin has stepped down, some prominent former Steelers players have spoken out against the head coach. The most notable player has probably been James Harrison. He made it clear that Tomlin wasn't deserving of making it into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, while also exposing how the coach treated him back when he was with the franchise. Recently, another defender came out and spoke about Tomlin in a negative light. Former linebacker Stevenson Sylvester recently went on 97.5 Scotty G. & Friends, and he shared why he believed Tomlin was not a good coach back when Sylvester was with the Steelers.

"When I was with the Steelers, we were 12-4 my first two seasons," Sylvester said. "Really good, top two, right next to Tom Brady's stupid self in the AFC. Then, my third year, we took a dip. We let go of some veterans. It wasn't as good as the years before. What I saw, the difference was Mike Tomlin would try to do everybody else's job. He would try to do the defensive coordinator's job, the linebacker coach's job, and it wouldn't leave time for those guys to do their job. That created dysfunction."

Sylvester played for the Steelers for four seasons after being selected by the franchise in the fifth round of the 2010 NFL Draft. His entire career in Pittsburgh, he had Tomlin as his head coach, and things went well for the most part. The Steelers played great when he first got there, but things started to fall off on the back half of his rookie contract, and he blamed Tomlin for creating dysfunction.

As mentioned, the Steelers went 12-4 in each of Sylvester's first two seasons, and the organization wound up losing the Super Bowl during his rookie year. In his last two seasons with the team, the Steelers went 8-8, missing the postseason in both years. 

That is quite the fall from grace for the franchise, and Sylvester blames Tomlin for meddling in too many things on his coaching staff. He seemingly didn't allow his assistant coaches to do their jobs. This was the first time the coach really hit a ton of adversity as the leader of the team, and he clearly did not know how to handle it. After winning the Super Bowl at the end of the 2008 season, Pittsburgh went 9-7 the next year and missed the postseason. That's an expected Super Bowl hangover and Tomlin was probably still riding the high of earning a Super Bowl ring. The back-to-back 8-8 seasons had a much worse effect.

Steelers' Mike Tomlin Has Been Accused Of Meddling With His Coaches Before

It is the head coach's job to make sure everything is operating smoothly, and he certainly gives his input on nearly everything. However, it was clear and obvious over the last several seasons that former defensive coordinator Teryl Austin was being forced to run a defense that just does not consistently work in today's NFL. He was calling the plays, but the defensive system was Tomlin's making. The coach is praised for his career, and he should be, but there are some blemishes on that resume as well.

What do you think about this story from Sylvester? Let me know on X, @brogannoey!

#SteelerNation