The Pittsburgh Steelers have been criticized a bit for their roster construction lately. In 2025, there were legitimate concerns about bringing in a bunch of players that were past their prime. In 2026, they went the exact opposite direction, with 11 players on the 53-man roster being rookies. General Manager Omar Khan is in a tough spot as his team has been unable to find any sort of stability at the quarterback position. Even Aaron Rodgers was more of a checkdown magnet in his first season in Pittsburgh, as opposed to what he was in years past.
Alysa Rubin / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' Aaron Rodgers at practice with Kenneth Gainwell and Arthur Smith ahead of the 2025 season opener.
One constant from both 2025 and 2026 has been the WR1. The Steelers are still expecting big things from DK Metcalf, even though he had a disappointing first year in Pittsburgh. The 2026 campaign did not start off well, as he had a few key drops despite the Week 1 win. He was targeted 10 times, but was only able to make 4 receptions off of those constant looks.
This may not be far off from what Steeler Nation should expect from the veteran receiver. While making an appearance on Steelers Collective, insider Ray Fittipaldo explained his mindset on what Metcalf is at this stage of his career.
"I'm just a little bit concerned about exactly who [DK Metcalf] is," Fittipaldo said. "[The Steelers] had visions of him being a true No. 1 receiver; that's why they're paying him $30 mil a year. I just have my doubts that he's ever going to be that guy."
Metcalf's 2025 season was the worst of his career, as he failed to rack up 900 yards for the first time. He is remembered more for his altercation with the fan than anything he did on the field that year. Everyone was talking about how it was a mistake to give up a second-round pick to get him and give him an exorbitant deal, especially since that helped give the Seattle Seahawks what they needed to win a Super Bowl.
2026 was expected to be different. Reports were coming out all throughout training camp that Rodgers and Metcalf had a better connection. They were on the same page more than they were in the previous season. This would be the year that the veteran wideout would catch his second wind and remind the world of how great he truly is, especially now that he has more help at the receiver position.
Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf (4) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
At the very least, there is a better connection, as Rodgers threw some very catchable balls to Metcalf. The receiver just didn't do his job well enough. The Steelers spent a lot of time and money searching for a WR2 to complement him, but as Fittipaldo said, it doesn't even look like they have a WR1. He has not shown anything to prove that he can be the leader of his position group since Pittsburgh traded for him.
Steelers May Have Hurt Themselves With Recent Money Move
The Steelers restructured Metcalf's contract to free up $18 million in 2026, with that money being converted to a signing bonus. That just makes it harder for Pittsburgh to let go of him in the future, as he is clearly not playing up to his contract. They could trade him after June 1 in future years to spread the dead cap out, but that's also not an ideal situation for someone that was supposed to help carry the offense.
There is still time for Metcalf to prove everyone wrong, but the clock is ticking. He can't be having these mental lapses that cause the various drops and outbursts throughout the season. If these struggles continue, Pittsburgh will have to have some very difficult conversations about him and his future on the team, even if it means eating a big chunk of dead cap.
What do you think about the doubts surrounding Metcalf's abilities at this point in his career? Let us know on X at @Steelers_ChrisB.
#SteelerNation