Steelers' Mike McCarthy Suddenly Leaks Future QB Plans To NBC's Cris Collinsworth (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers' Mike McCarthy Suddenly Leaks Future QB Plans To NBC's Cris Collinsworth

Alysa Rubin / Pittsburgh Steelers
author image

The Pittsburgh Steelers traveled to Ohio for an AFC North battle that was going to be especially telling. Unfortunately, they lost to the Cincinnati Bengals, 38-18, leaving plenty to address after a disappointing night. While the immediate concern is getting back on track, the broadcast also offered an interesting look at the future. Mike McCarthy apparently does not share the assumption that the Steelers must draft another quarterback after Aaron Rodgers retires.

Steelers Aaron Rodgers

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.

That possibility deserves attention because Drew Allar and Will Howard are already developing inside the building. The Steelers have young options to evaluate while Rodgers handles the starting responsibilities. Whether either becomes the answer remains an open question. 

However, McCarthy's perspective, as relayed by NBC analyst Cris Collinsworth, suggested their presence should factor into any discussion about next season.

During the broadcast, Collinsworth described a conversation he had with McCarthy the previous day. The discussion touched on the assumption that Rodgers' retirement would send the Steelers looking for another quarterback in the draft. According to Collinsworth, McCarthy pushed back by pointing toward the players he already has.

"[McCarthy] even brought up the idea that, 'Hey, everybody just assumes we're going to take a quarterback with Aaron retiring. We've got pretty good quarterbacks in here,'" Collinsworth said.

That is the part fans should take seriously without treating it as a promise. A coach expressing confidence in his quarterbacks does not mean the organization has closed the door on adding another one. It does mean the offseason conversation should include what the staff believes those players can become. 

The Steelers will have more information about their development than anyone judging from outside the building.

Steelers' Will Howard Drew Allar

© Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images

Jun 9, 2026; Pittsburgh, PA, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers quarterbacks Drew Allar (16) and Will Howard (18) participate in drills during Minicamp at UPMC Rooney Sports Complex.

For Allar and Howard, the opportunity is to make that confidence meaningful. Practice preparation, command of the offense and responses to coaching all contribute to an evaluation. 

Those things are harder for fans to measure than a completed pass on Sunday night. McCarthy and his assistants, however, have access to that work throughout the season. The next step would be showing enough consistency to earn an expanded role when the staff begins putting its plans for next year into practice.

Collinsworth then described the choice between adding another young quarterback and giving an opportunity to someone already being developed. That is where the discussion becomes particularly interesting. 

Drafting another prospect would mean comparing his potential against players the staff has spent months teaching. Familiarity does not guarantee better performance, but it can make the decision more informed.

"Do I want one of these young quarterbacks or do I want to take one of these guys that we've had a full year to develop here, and let them play," Collinsworth said. "If it falls to them in the right way, they probably would. If not, I think they just roll out Mason Rudolph. They've been impressed."

The reference to Mason Rudolph adds a veteran possibility, but the attribution matters. Collinsworth introduced that portion with his own assessment of what the Steelers might do. It should not be presented as McCarthy announcing Rudolph as the next starter. Likewise, the comments do not establish that Allar or Howard has been promised anything.


Steelers' Future Quarterback Possibilities Still Require Completely In The Air

Sunday night's loss should not turn a discussion about next season into an immediate demand to abandon this one. The Steelers still have games to prepare for and problems to correct with their current offense. Rodgers' retirement plans make the future relevant, but the staff must balance that preparation with its responsibility to compete now. Both tasks matter.

The encouraging possibility is that McCarthy sees enough in the existing room to consider giving it a genuine opportunity. The challenge is determining whether that belief holds up when a young quarterback must manage meaningful game situations. Development deserves patience, but eventually the Steelers need evidence that someone can handle the job. Another offseason will bring more decisions, not fewer expectations.


Share your Steelers quarterback thoughts with @anthonyghalkias on X, and follow for more coverage and discussion. Should Allar or Howard get the first chance after Rodgers, or would you prefer another addition?

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.