Steelers' Controversial Mason McCormick Block On Dexter Lawrence Sparks New Bengals Officiating Theory (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers' Controversial Mason McCormick Block On Dexter Lawrence Sparks New Bengals Officiating Theory

Barry Reeger / Imagn Images
author image

The Pittsburgh Steelers discovered just how much can change between divisional matchups during Sunday night's 38-18 loss to the Cincinnati Bengals. Pittsburgh's offensive line had been instrumental in its Week 3 victory over Cincinnati, helping the Steelers generate 411 yards of offense against a talented defensive front. Seven weeks later, the same group struggled to establish much of anything before losing one of its most dependable starters. However, one NFL analyst believes there may have been another interesting development behind the scenes that influenced how Cincinnati approached the rematch.

Steelers Mason McCormick

Katie Stratman / Imagn Images

Pittsburgh Steelers’ Mason McCormick is helped off the field after suffering an injury at Paycor Stadium in 2026.

During Monday's episode of the Check The Mic podcast, NFL analyst Sam Monson discussed Pittsburgh losing starting left guard Mason McCormick to a right ankle injury late in the first half. The conversation eventually shifted toward McCormick's previous encounter with Bengals defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence.

“Pittsburgh lost Mason McCormick. He was getting air casted off the field. That's not ideal from their offensive line point of view,” Monson said.

McCormick generated considerable attention following Pittsburgh's September victory when footage surfaced of him grabbing Lawrence's leg and lifting it off the ground while center Zach Frazier engaged the defensive tackle. The technique looked like something borrowed from a wrestling practice, and its legality became a topic of debate among former NFL players.

Monson believes Pittsburgh's inability to utilize that maneuver again contributed to Lawrence's effectiveness Sunday.

“I think it wasn't a coincidence that Dexter Lawrence was a bigger factor in this game than the first time around because they weren't able to just do the lift-up-his-leg thing and drive him off the line of scrimmage, which they did the first time, which is clearly illegal,” Monson said.

The analyst then offered an interesting theory regarding what Cincinnati might have done before traveling back onto the field against Pittsburgh.

“I would imagine Cincinnati made a point of emphasizing that to the officials,” Monson added.

There has been no public confirmation that Cincinnati actually contacted the officials about McCormick's blocking technique. Monson was offering his interpretation of what might have happened, although it would hardly be surprising if the Bengals wanted the officiating crew paying particular attention to the maneuver.

The legality of the original block is also more complicated than simply declaring it offensive holding. The NFL prohibits blockers from using their hands or arms to materially restrict a defender's movement, but its rulebook includes exceptions involving double-team blocks under certain circumstances. Determining whether McCormick violated the rule requires considering the entire sequence.

Pittsburgh had already anticipated that Lawrence might be looking for payback after their September encounter. Unfortunately, McCormick's injury prevented the two from battling for an entire evening.

Steelers' Dexter Lawrence

Katie Stratman / Imagn Images

Nov 1, 2026; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Cincinnati Bengals defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence II (97) enters the field before the game against the Tennessee Titans at Paycor Stadium.

Interestingly enough, Lawrence's individual statistics don't necessarily support Monson's assessment. The veteran recorded four tackles, two sacks and three tackles for loss during Pittsburgh's Week 3 victory. He finished Sunday's rematch with just one tackle for loss and no sacks.

However, those numbers don't account for every disruption Lawrence creates. A defensive tackle occupying multiple blockers can prevent an offensive lineman from reaching a linebacker, eliminate a rushing lane or create an opportunity for another pass rusher without receiving individual credit.

Pittsburgh running back Jaylen Warren rushed for 127 yards on 17 carries during the first meeting. Cincinnati held him to just 15 yards on seven attempts Sunday. The Steelers also spent considerably more time playing from behind, making it difficult to establish the same offensive rhythm they enjoyed in September.

Attributing that entire difference to one controversial blocking technique would be a stretch. Pittsburgh encountered problems across virtually every aspect of its offense, and losing McCormick only complicated matters further.


Steelers Have Bigger Concerns Than Their Previous Blocking Controversy

Head Coach Mike McCarthy indicated Monday that Pittsburgh was still gathering medical information regarding McCormick's injury. The organization has not publicly announced a definitive diagnosis or recovery timetable.

Veteran Spencer Anderson replaced McCormick against Cincinnati and could be responsible for working alongside Frazier moving forward.

Pittsburgh shouldn't need unconventional blocking techniques to establish an effective rushing attack. Frazier has developed into an excellent young center, and the organization has invested too heavily in its offensive line to depend on maneuvers that leave everybody debating the rulebook afterward.

Monson's theory certainly adds another interesting chapter to the rivalry between Pittsburgh and Cincinnati. However, the Steelers now have to figure out how to maintain their physical identity without the offensive lineman who helped create it.

Lawrence and the Bengals may have entered Sunday particularly interested in what McCormick was doing with his hands. Pittsburgh will spend the coming weeks hoping it can get those hands back on a football field.


#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.