Steelers Get Alarming Assessment Of Rookie As Left Guard Problem Grows (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers Get Alarming Assessment Of Rookie As Left Guard Problem Grows

Jordan Perez / Pittsburah Steelers
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers watched a painful loss against the Cincinnati Bengals become even more painful when starting left guard Mason McCormick suffered an apparent serious ankle injury. With his availability in doubt, the Steelers need to figure out what happens next at left guard. That puts Spencer Anderson back in the spotlight. It also raises questions about how much rookie Gennings Dunker can realistically offer right now.

Steelers Gennings Dunker

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Pittsburgh Steelers offensive lineman Gennings Dunker (73) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.

Steelers insiders Ray Fittipaldo and Mark Kaboly discussed those options on Steelers Collective on Tuesday. Their assessment offered little comfort for anyone expecting Dunker to immediately replace McCormick without complications. Kaboly described a potentially limited role for the rookie. Fittipaldo pointed toward Anderson as the player who needs to deliver.

The concern is palpable after McCormick left Sunday's game on a cart with an air cast on his right leg. Losing him means disrupting a line that has spent the season building familiarity. The Steelers need someone who can handle a full assignment, rather than force the offense to work around obvious limitations. Kaboly's comments suggested Dunker might require precisely that kind of accommodation.

"If you're throwing him out there, you may have to rotate him in, like every time we wanna run power, let's throw him out there," Kaboly said. "Everything else, let's take him back out."

That is an alarming assessment of readiness, even though it remains Kaboly's evaluation rather than an announcement from the coaching staff. A guard who can help on selected rushing plays is not automatically prepared to handle an entire game. The Steelers need protection, communication and execution across different situations. Replacing McCormick cannot simply become a matter of finding someone who moves defenders on power runs.

There is another practical problem with a role that narrow. If a particular substitution regularly accompanies a particular concept, opponents have another clue about what might be coming. The offense can disguise that tendency or build counters from it, but doing so creates additional work. Ideally, the replacement allows Mike McCarthy to keep the full menu available.

Steelers Mike McCarthy Omar Khan

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Pittsburgh Steelers Head Coach Mike McCarthy stands alongside General Manager Omar Khan as the two watch the team practice during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.

Dunker also remains on injured reserve, adding an availability consideration to the discussion about his development. His health and readiness must both be evaluated before any expanded role becomes realistic. None of this means his future is already defined. It means the Steelers have an immediate need that cannot be answered through potential alone.

Fittipaldo believes Anderson has to meet that need. He acknowledged Anderson's previous work as a spot starter while also noting that he lost his starting job. This opportunity, in Fittipaldo's view, gives Anderson a chance to change the direction of his season.

"Spencer has to be the answer," Fittipaldo said. "He's been a good spot starter over the years, but you're right, he's lost his job, and this is a big second opportunity for him."

Steelers Need Anderson's Redemption As Rookie Questions Grow

Anderson does not need to approach this as a chance to prove every critic wrong on one snap. He needs to provide steady play, communicate clearly and avoid the mistakes that derail possessions. Protecting Aaron Rodgers requires all five linemen to understand how their responsibilities fit together. McCormick's replacement has to earn that trust through repetition and dependable execution. That starts with handling ordinary downs well enough that McCarthy does not have to change his entire approach just to get through a game without another setback.

Fittipaldo also raised the financial opportunity, describing Anderson as a player working toward his next contract. A strong finish could improve how teams view him, whether his future remains with the Steelers or takes him elsewhere. That is Fittipaldo's projection, not a guarantee of a payday. The immediate priority is showing that the offense can count on him.

For Dunker, the goal should be progress without pretending the circumstances are ideal. For Anderson, the opening is more urgent: the Steelers need a workable answer now. McCormick's injury has created a difficult situation, and the remaining linemen must help keep it from becoming a weekly problem. 


Share your Pittsburgh Steelers thoughts with @anthonyghalkias on X, and follow for more coverage and discussion. Can Anderson make the most of this second chance, or would you eventually give Dunker an opportunity?

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.