Steelers Now Have To Explore Trading TJ Watt: "Would Be The Smartest One" (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers Now Have To Explore Trading TJ Watt: "Would Be The Smartest One"

Alysa Rubin / Pittsburgh Steelers
author image

The Pittsburgh Steelers are one of the best teams in the league when it comes to the franchise's outside linebacker room, and that is also shown when looking at the salary cap table. There are several players on big contracts at the position in Pittsburgh, and the team can't seem to always get the most production from the group. That falls on the players themselves as well as the coaching staff. The edge rushers have to be put in position to succeed, and that was not happening in Week 10 because the secondary was playing so far off of the wide receivers of the Cincinnati Bengals.

Steelers Defense 2025

Karl Roser / Pittsburgh Steelers

Steelers' TJ Watt and Keeanu Benton celebrate after a big play during a regular season game in 2025 against the Bengals.

The Steelers rely on the edge rushers to make plays against powerful offenses, and that did not happen at all during the team's embarrassing loss to the Cincinnati Bengals on Sunday. Pittsburgh is now 6-3 and is still in line to make the postseason, but it is hard to imagine the team really being taken seriously if it does stumble into the playoffs. The offense can't keep up with the other powerful units in the AFC, and the defense is still running into the same issues it has had in recent years.

It has become clear that team building is a problem in Pittsburgh. The offense lacks legitimate weapons while the defense has several holes in the secondary. It would only make sense if the franchise were to decide to move on from one of the highly-paid outside linebackers during the 2027 season. Beat writer Mark Kaboly spoke about this on a recent episode of Steelers Collective, and he shared that TJ Watt would be the smartest player to move on from.

"They're in a tough situation," Kaboly said. "Obviously Herbig's married to the team, right? Can't get rid of him. Honestly, Watt would be the smartest one, but we know that's not going to happen. He's having a pretty solid season and this that and another. I guess the best case scenario, and it might not be in the cards, is TJ just wanted to retire. I don't see that happening, but what do you do? You trade Highsmith and then TJ retires or plays somewhere else in a year and a half?"

Watt, Alex Highsmith, and Nick Herbig are all making big money at outside linebacker. Herbig just signed his extension during the 2026 offseason, so he is not going anywhere. Watt is signed through the 2028 season, and Highsmith has one year left on his deal after this one. That makes him the top trade candidate of the three players going into the 2027 offseason.

Steelers' Alex Highsmith

Jordan Perez / Pittsburgh Steelers

Steelers linebacker Alex Highsmith rushes the passer during a regular-season game against the Bengals in November 2026.

Highsmith is largely under-appreciated by the fan base in Pittsburgh, and Kaboly is absolutely right. Trading Watt would make the most sense, but the Steelers missed the chance to do that ahead of the 2025 season when the franchise signed him to a new extension that made him the highest-paid non-quarterback in the league for a short period of time. The Steelers should have dealt him then, but the organization decided to keep all three players and throw even more money at the position in what was yet another questionable decision by this franchise.


Steelers Don't Need To Get Rid Of Anyone

Pittsburgh can keep all three players for the 2027 season, but it probably wouldn't be wise to. The franchise needs to move forward as a team that is going through a bit of a rebuild, and Watt might not want to stick around for that. Highsmith may also want a new deal before playing in 2027, so trading him would make sense. If an organization is moving forward with the idea of going through some form of rebuild, it only makes sense to try to bring in as much draft capital as possible.


What would you do if you were the Steelers? Would you trade anyone? Let me know on X, @brogannoey!

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.