The Pittsburgh Steelers have spent years watching college quarterbacks become the subject of increasingly unrealistic offseason fantasies. Every promising prospect seemingly becomes the organization's next franchise quarterback before Pittsburgh even knows where it will be selecting in the NFL Draft. The conversation has become particularly interesting with Aaron Rodgers planning to retire following the 2026 season. However, one longtime Steelers insider believes Pittsburgh might already have a quarterback with enough potential to justify staying away from one of college football's biggest attractions.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Drew Allar (16) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
Steelers insider Mark Kaboly discussed the organization's future at quarterback during a Wednesday appearance on 93.7 The Fan. When presented with the possibility of Pittsburgh selecting Texas quarterback Arch Manning in the 2027 NFL Draft, Kaboly questioned whether the Steelers would actually be upgrading over rookie quarterback Drew Allar.
“He's definitely going to be a first-rounder, I think. I mean, just for the lack of other guys, you know, in the draft this year who's even decent. But is he much different than what you have with Drew Allar right now?” Kaboly asked.
Manning has been one of the most recognizable names in college football since arriving at Texas in 2023. However, the conversation surrounding his professional future has become considerably more complicated than many anticipated. The Texas quarterback has thrown for 2,198 yards, 19 touchdowns and 10 interceptions through 10 games this season.
Manning will participate in Texas' Senior Day festivities against Arkansas on Saturday, but he has not announced whether he intends to enter the 2027 NFL Draft or return for another season.
Kaboly believes Pittsburgh would be better served continuing to develop its third-round investment than potentially sacrificing valuable draft capital to acquire Manning.
“I don't think so. I think those two are maybe not similar in game, but similar in, you know, the ceiling type of thing. So, I would go more with Drew Allar over that,” Kaboly said.
There is some interesting perspective behind Kaboly's argument. Before his final season at Penn State, Allar was generating plenty of first-round speculation himself. An inconsistent senior campaign and a broken ankle ultimately contributed to him falling to Pittsburgh with the 76th overall selection.
Allar threw for 3,327 yards, 24 touchdowns and eight interceptions during his junior season, helping Penn State reach the College Football Playoff semifinals. His arm strength was never really in question. Getting his feet, timing and decision-making to consistently cooperate with that arm presented a considerably more difficult assignment.
Manning isn't immune to those same developmental concerns. His ability to extend plays and deliver throws from uncomfortable platforms is impressive, but his consistency working through progressions remains an area of concern.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Steelers General Manager Omar Khan during a training camp practice in Latrobe, PA.
The financial and roster-building implications also make Kaboly's argument worth considering. With Pittsburgh sitting at 6-3, the organization currently projects to select 23rd overall in the 2027 NFL Draft.
If Manning eventually becomes a highly coveted prospect, General Manager Omar Khan could find himself negotiating an expensive move up the draft board. Allar, meanwhile, is already under contract through 2029 on an inexpensive rookie deal.
The Steelers are essentially getting a year to evaluate Allar before deciding whether they need to spend considerably more money or draft capital addressing the same position.
Head Coach Mike McCarthy has apparently made encouraging progress with Allar behind the scenes. Kaboly has previously discussed the organization's growing confidence in the rookie, suggesting Pittsburgh could already be leaning toward giving him a legitimate opportunity to start in 2027.
However, Allar remains fourth on Pittsburgh's official depth chart behind Rodgers, Mason Rudolph and Will Howard.
He completed 55.6% of his passes during the preseason, throwing for 351 yards and two touchdowns without an interception. His impressive debut against the Green Bay Packers was followed by two considerably less productive outings. Pittsburgh still has plenty to learn about him.
Steelers Shouldn't Let Arch Manning's Last Name Dictate Their Quarterback Plans
The Steelers would be foolish to trade significant draft capital for Manning simply because he spent years being advertised as the next great NFL quarterback. Allar was once viewed as a potential first-round selection himself, and Pittsburgh acquired him without having to surrender multiple premium picks.
That doesn't mean the organization should remove Manning from its draft board. If Pittsburgh's evaluations eventually determine that Manning possesses a significantly higher ceiling, Khan needs to remain open to pursuing him. Finding a franchise quarterback is too important to let a previous third-round investment dictate every subsequent decision.
However, McCarthy deserves an opportunity to demonstrate what he can accomplish with the quarterback he selected in April. If Allar continues developing, Pittsburgh could enter the offseason with an entirely different set of priorities.
The Steelers have already purchased a lottery ticket at quarterback. Before spending considerably more on another one, they might want to see whether the first one is worth anything.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

