Steelers Urged To Commit To Drew Allar As Their 2027 Starter (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers Urged To Commit To Drew Allar As Their 2027 Starter

Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers have spent enough time conducting experiments at quarterback to open their own laboratory. Between first-round investments, reclamation projects and future Hall of Famers nearing retirement, Pittsburgh has seemingly tried everything since the beginning of the 2022 season. With Aaron Rodgers planning to retire following the 2026 campaign, the organization will once again find itself searching for an answer at football's most important position. However, one longtime Steelers insider believes Pittsburgh should approach its upcoming quarterback decision much differently than it has in previous years.

Steelers Drew Allar

Jordan Perez / Pittsburgh Steelers

Steelers quarterback Drew Allar rolls out to throw in a preseason game against the Buffalo Bills in 2026.

Steelers insider Mark Kaboly discussed Pittsburgh's quarterback plans during a Wednesday appearance on 93.7 The Fan. Kaboly believes rookie quarterback Drew Allar represents the organization's best option for 2027, but his argument goes beyond simply giving the former Penn State standout an opportunity to compete for the starting job.

Kaboly wants Pittsburgh to make a commitment.

“You have to commit to it. You have to do it. You have to say, ‘Okay, this is it.’ You have to commit to it. Unless they feel the same about all these guys and make it an open competition, that's hard to come up with the right winner at that point. You got to feel strongly,” Kaboly said.

There is an interesting argument to be made about the disadvantages of conducting an extended quarterback competition. The player who eventually wins the job will have spent a considerable portion of the offseason splitting valuable repetitions with somebody who might not take a meaningful snap during the regular season.

For an inexperienced quarterback learning how to operate an NFL offense, those opportunities are particularly valuable. Establishing timing with receivers, communicating protection adjustments and developing chemistry with the starting offensive line are considerably easier when everybody knows who will be under center.

Kaboly also pointed toward Head Coach Mike McCarthy as one of the biggest reasons Pittsburgh should feel comfortable committing to Allar.

“If they feel strongly about Drew Allar, he was a third-round pick. He was Mike McCarthy's hand-chosen pick. He likes something about the guy. That's the way to go. Then go,” Kaboly said.

McCarthy wasn't in Pittsburgh when the organization selected Will Howard in the sixth round of the 2025 NFL Draft. Allar, however, went through the evaluation process with McCarthy in charge before the organization selected him 76th overall in April.

McCarthy has previously revealed that Pittsburgh's personnel department viewed Allar as a first-round talent following his junior season at Penn State. Getting him in the third round provided the organization with an opportunity to develop a quarterback it believed possessed considerable upside without making an enormous financial or draft investment.

Steelers' Mike McCarthy

Karl Roser / Pittsburgh Steelers

Steelers' Mike McCarthy coaches up rookie quarterback Drew Allar during rookie minicamp in 2026.

Allar's development throughout his rookie campaign has apparently given Kaboly additional confidence. The insider recently suggested the young quarterback has made noticeable progress since arriving in Pittsburgh and should receive every opportunity to become the starter next season.

The difference between giving somebody every opportunity and actually handing him the job, however, is substantial.

Allar remains fourth on Pittsburgh's depth chart behind Rodgers, Mason Rudolph and Howard. He completed 55.6% of his passes during the preseason, throwing for 351 yards and two touchdowns without an interception. There were encouraging moments, but there wasn't nearly enough evidence to establish that Allar is unquestionably the best quarterback Pittsburgh will have available next season.

Howard also deserves consideration. McCarthy praised the second-year quarterback's football intelligence and athleticism during the offseason, and being selected by the previous coaching staff shouldn't automatically disqualify him from becoming the franchise's next starter.

Still, McCarthy has an entire season to evaluate both young quarterbacks before making that decision. Pittsburgh shouldn't necessarily need another three months of training camp discussions to determine which one the coaching staff believes has the brighter future.


Steelers Should Give Allar The Offseason Of A Starting Quarterback

If McCarthy genuinely believes Allar is the organization's best option entering 2027, Pittsburgh should give him the responsibilities that come with being the starter from the beginning of the offseason.

Let him establish relationships with his receivers. Give him an opportunity to influence the installation of the offense. Allow him to make mistakes while working with the starting personnel rather than constantly wondering whether one bad afternoon will send him down the depth chart.

General Manager Omar Khan should still explore other opportunities at quarterback if the circumstances warrant it. Committing to Allar simply because Pittsburgh selected him in the third round would be every bit as irresponsible as overlooking him because he wasn't selected in the first.

However, the Steelers hired McCarthy in part because of his reputation for developing quarterbacks. If he determines Allar is ready to become his next project under center, the organization should trust that evaluation enough to give the young quarterback a legitimate runway.

Pittsburgh has spent several seasons searching for stability at quarterback. Creating another summer of uncertainty might not be the best way to finally achieve it.


#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.