The Pittsburgh Steelers could enter the 2027 offseason with a rather uncomfortable quarterback decision. For an organization that has spent years trying to remain competitive while searching for its next franchise signal-caller, there is something appealing about having an experienced veteran available to keep everything afloat. However, Pittsburgh eventually needs to stop prioritizing the immediate comfort of its coaching staff over the development of its younger players. One longtime Steelers insider believes the organization should establish some pretty significant conditions before allowing another veteran to lead its offense next season.

Barry Reeger / Imagn Images
Steelers' Mike McCarthy with backup quarterback Mason Rudolph during a home win over the Cincinnati Bengals in 2026.
Steelers insider Mark Kaboly discussed the possibility of Mason Rudolph becoming Pittsburgh's starting quarterback in 2027 during a Wednesday appearance on 93.7 The Fan. While Kaboly wasn't completely opposed to bringing Rudolph back following the anticipated retirement of Aaron Rodgers, he believes the veteran should only become the starter under very specific circumstances.
“I don't mind it, but it has to be a lot of caveats attached to it, I think,” Kaboly said.
Rudolph is playing on the final year of the two-year, $7.5 million contract he signed upon returning to Pittsburgh in March of 2025. The 31-year-old is scheduled to become an unrestricted free agent following the season, giving him some control over whether he wants to remain with the organization.
Kaboly explained that Pittsburgh's two younger quarterbacks, Drew Allar and Will Howard, would need to disappoint considerably before Rudolph should even be considered for the starting job.
“I think if he comes back, I think it's under the impression that Allar and/or Howard has to fail miserably for him to get the Week 1 start,” Kaboly said.
It's difficult to argue against bringing Rudolph back as an experienced backup. Pittsburgh already demonstrated how much it values having him available by retaining four quarterbacks this season despite the unusual roster construction. The organization also had legitimate reasons to keep Rudolph around when his name surfaced in discussions surrounding the trade deadline.
His experience has value, particularly for a coaching staff that could be working with a first-time starter next season.
However, convincing Rudolph to return under those conditions might be an entirely different conversation. The veteran will be entering his 10th NFL season in 2027, and another opportunity to compete for a starting job elsewhere could be more attractive than returning to Pittsburgh as somebody else's insurance policy.

Barry Reeger / Imagn Images
Aug 13, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers quarterbacks Will Howard (18) and Drew Allar (16) warm up for a pre-season game against the Green Bay Packers at Acrisure Stadium.
Rudolph has started 19 regular-season games throughout his career, throwing for 4,927 yards, 30 touchdowns and 22 interceptions. His best stretch in Pittsburgh came at the end of the 2023 season when he helped the Steelers win three consecutive games and sneak into the postseason.
Unfortunately, Steelers fans also remember what happened the following offseason. Rudolph departed for the Tennessee Titans, where he threw nine touchdowns and nine interceptions across eight appearances in 2024. His time in Tennessee provided additional evidence that he can function as an NFL starter, but sustaining that production over an extended period remains another question.
Pittsburgh already has a pretty good understanding of what Rudolph brings to the position. The same cannot be said about Allar or Howard.
General Manager Omar Khan kept both young quarterbacks on the active roster because the organization believes there is something worth developing. Neither has attempted a pass in a regular-season NFL game, which makes evaluating their potential considerably more difficult.
Head Coach Mike McCarthy will eventually need to determine whether their development throughout the week can translate to Sundays. Another season of watching a veteran handle the starting responsibilities would only delay that process.
Steelers Should Bring Rudolph Back Without Promising Him The Starting Job
The ideal outcome for Pittsburgh would involve re-signing Rudolph while giving Allar or Howard the first opportunity to lead the offense. Having an experienced backup available would give McCarthy some flexibility if the younger starter struggles without forcing the organization to immediately abandon its developmental plans.
The Steelers also need to be careful about what constitutes failure. A young quarterback throwing a couple of interceptions during his first month as an NFL starter shouldn't automatically result in Rudolph taking over. Development rarely follows a straight line, especially for quarterbacks selected outside the first round.
Pittsburgh should be willing to tolerate some growing pains if McCarthy sees meaningful progress in the areas that actually determine a quarterback's long-term success.
Rudolph has earned considerable respect for the way he has handled his opportunities throughout his career. Bringing him back would be perfectly reasonable, provided both sides understand what his role is supposed to be.
The Steelers need a dependable backup quarterback in 2027. They shouldn't spend another offseason confusing that need with finding their next franchise starter.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

