Steelers' Mike McCarthy And Aaron Rodgers Still Appear To Be Argumentative (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers' Mike McCarthy And Aaron Rodgers Still Appear To Be Argumentative

Kirby Lee / Imagn Images
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers initially hired Head Coach Mike McCarthy with the idea of getting this stagnant offense to finally play up to the rest of the NFL. Him being brought in helped to convince Aaron Rodgers to return for one more season, as the two know each other very well. The idea was that having that level of familiarity from the coach would allow the 42-year-old quarterback to go back in time a bit and play closer to his Green Bay Packers form than he has since leaving that team. 

Steelers Mike McCarthy Aaron Rodgers

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Pittsburgh Steelers Head Coach Mike McCarthy (left) and quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.

So far, that has not worked. When the offense has been doing well, it's been mostly because of the run game, as Jaylen Warren has been one of the best running backs in the NFL. The Steelers have not done well when they rely on the passing game to sustain drives. Rodgers looks more like a player about to retire than someone who can be the reason his team wins a playoff game. 

Things don't seem to be all sunshine and rainbows with this reunion. Steelers reporter Christopher Carter asked both McCarthy and Rodgers about using more play-action, and their answers did not exactly line up, as Donny Chedrick noted.

"Mike McCarthy & Aaron Rodgers answers when asked by @CarterCritiques about running more play-action: McCarthy: 'I would like to do more.' Rodgers: 'That's not a question for me,'" Chedrick noted. "Seems like the coach wants it, but the QB doesn't. The Steelers' PA usage ranks 29th in the NFL."

While Rodgers didn't outright throw his coach under the bus, it's not hard to read between the lines. If the veteran quarterback wanted to run more play-action, they would have done it by now, as opposed to running it the fourth-least amount through 10 weeks. This begs the question of why the Steelers wanted this reunion, because this isn't the only thing that the two men butt heads about. 

Steelers' Mike McCarthy

X: @JomboyMedia

Mike McCarthy and Aaron Rodgers curse each other out during a Week 4 game against the Browns.

At the end of the day, McCarthy is right. Chedrick pulled up the Steelers' analytics when they utilize play-action versus when they don't, and the numbers do a good job of telling the story. 

It's very clear that Rodgers is not a top tier quarterback anymore, and these receivers aren't exactly the best in the NFL either. The Steelers need to capitalize on their dynamic run game by utilizing play-action. That way, these receivers can actually get open more consistently in the middle of the field when the linebackers and safeties walk down to defend the run that's not coming. This would be a big boost to this struggling offense.

The biggest reason why Rodgers may want to avoid this is timing. At this point in his career, the 42-year-old doesn't want to get hit, so he has a tendency to get the ball out quickly, whether it's his first read or the checkdown. The play-action can take a while to develop, so if the blocking isn't very good, he could take a big hit before getting the chance to throw the ball, and that would make him against it.


Steelers Keep Putting Themselves At Disadvantage Due To McCarthy And Rodgers

Throughout the entire 2026 season, the Steelers keep having issues where they don't break the huddle until there's less than 10 seconds on the clock due to the real-time communication. That gives Rodgers no time to make checks and audibles while opposing defenses can home in on when the snap is coming. It sometimes results in timeouts taken, delay of game penalties, or even him and McCarthy cursing each other out. 


What do you think about McCarthy and Rodgers not being on the same page with play-action usage? Let us know on X at @Steelers_ChrisB.

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.