The Pittsburgh Steelers have a bit of a problem. First-round picks are supposed to become the players a franchise builds around, but Pittsburgh has gone too long without consistently getting that return. Now Troy Fautanu is approaching a contract decision that puts the organization's recent draft history back under the microscope.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Steelers' offensive lineman Troy Fautanu stands on the playing surface as the team warms up on the field prior to a 2025 training camp practice being held at St. Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
The question is whether Fautanu has done enough to make his fifth-year option an easy choice. His draft position alone cannot answer that, and neither can the Steelers' need for stability up front. Pittsburgh needs to feel comfortable paying for the player he has become, rather than the player it hoped he would become.
That concern came up on The Snap Count, where Charlie Batch connected Fautanu's future to a troubling pattern. Batch pointed to TJ Watt, drafted in 2017, as the last Steelers first-round selection whose fifth-year option Pittsburgh exercised. He then turned his attention to the next player facing that evaluation.
"That's a problem. Right now, the next player in line is Troy Fautanu," Batch said. "Has he done enough to prove that he now earned a fifth-year contract? We don't know. That's something that will have to figure itself out over the next eight weeks."
Batch's question gets right to the frustration. The Steelers should be excited about keeping their first-round players, especially at positions where dependable starters are difficult to find. Instead, another important decision comes with enough uncertainty to make fans wonder whether the same conversation is happening again.
The history deserves some context. Terrell Edmunds, Devin Bush and Najee Harris had their options declined, while Kenny Pickett was traded before Pittsburgh reached that decision on his contract. Broderick Jones also had his option declined earlier this year, extending the run Batch was discussing.
%202023%20Camp%20Final%20with%20Logos/2L9A5105-original.jpg)
Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: JSKO_PHOTO)
Former Steelers QB Kenny Pickett during the offseason.
Every player on that list has a different story, and a declined option doesn't mean a pick was a total failure. The Steelers also didn't have a first-round pick in 2020. Still, Pittsburgh keeps investing premium picks in players without getting enough long-term answers, and that should concern Steeler Nation.
Fautanu should be judged on his own work, though. He cannot fix what happened with previous selections, and those players' outcomes should not become evidence against him. What he can do is give Pittsburgh more reasons to trust him through his performance over the remainder of this season.
There is also an important distinction between the decision date and the season the option covers. Fautanu remains under contract through 2027, and Pittsburgh's decision comes during the 2027 offseason. Exercising the option would extend his rookie contract through 2028, rather than represent an immediate new multiyear agreement.
That timeline gives the Steelers room to evaluate him without pretending his future has already been settled. Batch's reference to the next eight weeks emphasizes the opportunity in front of Fautanu. Those games can strengthen his case, even though the decision comes later.
The standard should be dependable play. Pittsburgh needs a tackle who handles his assignments, limits avoidable mistakes and gives the offense a chance to operate. Occasional encouraging stretches help, but consistency is what makes a significant commitment easier to justify.
Steelers Need Fautanu To Break Their Brutal Option Pattern
For the front office, the challenge is avoiding a decision driven by frustration with the past. Exercising an option simply to end an embarrassing trend would accomplish nothing. Declining it because previous first-rounders disappointed would be just as misguided.
Fautanu has an opportunity to turn this into a much more comfortable conversation. Every reliable performance gives Pittsburgh another reason to believe its investment is paying off. Every unresolved issue leaves the organization weighing the cost against the uncertainty.
Has Fautanu shown enough to earn his fifth-year option? Share your Pittsburgh Steelers thoughts on X with @anthonyghalkias, and follow for more Steelers coverage, draft discussion and roster debates.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

