The Pittsburgh Steelers are operating under a completely different philosophy now that Mike McCarthy is at the helm. For 19 seasons, Steelers fans knew exactly what type of coaching, leadership, and culture the team represented under Mike Tomlin. His tenure brought consistency, stability, and a clear identity to Pittsburgh football. However, with Tomlin no longer leading the organization, McCarthy appears determined to change the direction of the franchise and bring a new approach to the Steelers.
Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images
Steelers Head Coach Mike McCarthy stands in front of the media to answer questions as the team goes through 2026 mandatory minicamp workouts in Pittsburgh, PA.
That shift starts with the structure around the team. McCarthy has added additional members to the coaching staff that Tomlin never had during his time in Pittsburgh, while also placing a greater emphasis on the offensive side of the football. The changes suggest a more modern approach, but the biggest difference may come in how McCarthy handles accountability inside the locker room. One of the biggest criticisms of Tomlin during the later stages of his coaching career was whether he maintained the same level of accountability that helped define the Steelers’ culture for so many years.
For a coach who was widely respected as one of the best leaders of men in football, it was sometimes surprising to see certain players develop larger personalities or seemingly avoid consequences under Tomlin’s watch. Whether that was a result of Tomlin’s approach, players taking advantage of their status, or a combination of both, many believed the Steelers had lost some of the edge that once made them one of the league’s toughest organizations. Several former Steelers players have even spoken about noticing that accountability slipping during the later years of Tomlin’s tenure.
That is why comments from Steelers insider Ray Fittipaldo during Tuesday’s episode of the Steelers Collective Podcast with Mark Kaboly generated so much attention. Fittipaldo highlighted a major point regarding McCarthy’s new approach and explained why Joey Porter Jr. may not receive the same level of patience or favoritism he potentially would have under Tomlin. With a new coaching philosophy in place, every player, regardless of name or status, may now be expected to earn their role every single day.
"In years past, guys, it’s kind of been a wink-wink, 'Hey, you are going to hold-in and do what’s best for your family,' they were okay with that because the Steelers wanted their assets ready for the season," Fittipaldo said. "I just wonder if Mike McCarthy is a little more hard-lined than Mike Tomlin was. I think Mike Tomlin was a little more player-friendly. I think he took the players’ side in these negotiations and, you know, with the coaching change, maybe that’s not the case any longer."
As Steelers GM Omar Khan took the podium to address the media on Tuesday as the team reported to training camp in Latrobe, he made it clear that Donte Kent and Jalen Ramsey would begin training camp on the Physically Unable to Perform (PUP) list. What shocked many, however, was what happened about an hour later when it was revealed that Porter would also be joining Kent and Ramsey on the list. The move was unexpected, raising questions about whether McCarthy and Khan were aware that Porter would be placed on PUP.
Barry Reeger / Imagn Images
Pittsburgh Steelers cornerback Joey Porter Jr. leaves the field following an AFC Wild Card Round loss to the Houston Texans at Acrisure Stadium.
Porter’s situation comes at a time when he is seeking a contract extension as the cornerback market continues to rise. Many Steelers fans believe the price will only continue to climb and that Pittsburgh should pay him before the market gets even more expensive. Others are wondering if there is more behind the decision to place him on PUP, especially given the timing and whether the stalled contract negotiations played any role in the move.
Steelers Still Expected To Get Deal Done With Porter
Kaboly added to Fittipaldo’s comments, explaining that he does not believe there is anything major happening behind the scenes. Both Steelers insiders believe Porter will eventually get a deal done for the money he is looking for, which is reportedly expected to fall somewhere between $25 million and $32 million per year. Whether this is simply a precautionary move or a sign of a new accountability standard under McCarthy, the Porter situation will be one of the biggest storylines to watch throughout training camp.
Please feel free to share your Steelers takes with me on X (@anthonyghalkias) and consider following for more Steelers-related content and discussion.
#SteelerNation