The Pittsburgh Steelers are still hearing about what happened in Cincinnati, and one of the latest critics knows the franchise from the inside. A former Steelers receiver who spent four seasons in Pittsburgh watched the 38-18 loss and came away confused by how the defense chose to play the Bengals' star receivers. His take lines up with what a lot of fans saw on Sunday night, and it raises a bigger question about whether the Steelers have the right cornerbacks to handle the top receivers on their schedule.

Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images
Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker Nick Herbig (51), cornerback Asante Samuel Jr. (22), linebacker Patrick Queen (6) and cornerback Brandin Echols on the field during a 2026 game.
Former Steelers wide receiver Emmanuel Sanders broke down the game on Tuesday's episode of The Matchup, the show he co-hosts with former Denver Broncos teammate Chris Harris Jr. Their guest was another Super Bowl 50 champion, former Broncos defensive lineman Derek Wolfe.
Sanders opened by praising what the Cincinnati Bengals did through the air. Then he turned to the other sideline and didn't hold back about Pittsburgh's approach.
"When I watch the Steelers, these guys are scared of Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. They're playing 15 yards off the ball," Sanders said.
Sanders explained that the soft coverage handed Cincinnati the easy throws all night. In his view, the cushion gave the Bengals' receivers the hitch routes and the stop routes underneath, and Joe Burrow was happy to take them. He said he kept asking himself why the Steelers were playing that way, and he pointed out that a physical defense like Denver's would have challenged those receivers at the line instead.
The results back up the frustration. Burrow threw for 406 yards and four touchdowns, according to Local 12. Ja'Marr Chase did most of the damage with 11 catches for 231 yards, while Tee Higgins added five catches for 66 yards. Burrow put up more than 300 passing yards in the first half alone.
Wolfe added that the Bengals' offensive line did a great job against TJ Watt, calling Watt a top-three pass rusher and saying Cincinnati completely shut him down. He also said the way the Steelers' defense was playing off made it look like a game against a college team.

Barry Reeger / Imagn Images
New York Jets tight end Jelani Woods (86) scores a touchdown in front of Pittsburgh Steelers safety DeShon Elliott (25).
Harris, a four-time Pro Bowl cornerback, offered an explanation for the cushion. He said it comes down to the scheme and the type of cornerbacks the Steelers have now. Without Joey Porter Jr., Pittsburgh doesn't have a big press corner who can get physical with receivers like Chase and Higgins and run with them down the field.
"Now you're seeing why you don't get rid of a guy like Joey Porter, right? You need him in the division," Harris said.
Harris described Asante Samuel Jr. as a smaller corner who does his best work in off coverage. That plan backfired on Sunday, as Chase was able to run right past him. Harris added that the Steelers will need to find a true No. 1 cornerback in the offseason.
It is a familiar debate. The coverage plan has been picked apart all week, and some local voices have argued that pressing Cincinnati's receivers would have led to even bigger plays over the top. Defensive Coordinator Patrick Graham admitted on Monday that the defense got punched in the mouth.
Steelers Cornerback Room Faces Big Questions
Sanders and Harris both touched on the same bigger issue. Teams in the AFC North have to deal with Chase and Higgins twice a year, and a cornerback room built on off coverage is going to be tested every time. The Steelers have already made moves this week, signing a corner to the practice squad and working out other veteran defensive backs.
The next test comes Sunday against the Philadelphia Eagles. Whether the Steelers stick with their coverage plan or play more aggressive man coverage on the outside will say a lot about how the coaching staff feels about this group. SteelerNation will find out soon whether Sanders' criticism sticks.
This story was produced with the help of AI and reviewed by SteelerNation editors.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

