Steelers' Playoff Chances Exposed By An Aaron Rodgers-Sized Problem (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers' Playoff Chances Exposed By An Aaron Rodgers-Sized Problem

Kirby Lee / Imagn Images
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers suffered a brutal loss at the hands of a tough, now 7-2, Cincinnati Bengals in an embarrassing fashion. After a trade deadline that saw the team make no moves at all, the glaring weaknesses on the roster were on full display in this Week 10 matchup. Fans were hoping that the front office would make a splash for a variety of seemingly available wide receivers and cornerbacks, however, nothing came to fruition. Pittsburgh seemed reluctant to give up its valuable draft capital and settled on staying put. The lack of run game early forced the Steelers to throw, which highlighted the lack of weapons on the offense. The aging signal-caller, Aaron Rodgers, struggled to throw his receivers open, like DK Metcalf, who found the end zone when the game was already out of reach. 

Steelers DK Metcalf

Karl Roser / Pittsburgh Steelers

DK Metcalf lines up for the Steelers during a regular-season game against the Cincinnati Bengals at Acrisure Stadium in 2025.

Rodgers has been among the league's elite for two decades now, and 2025 saw him become more methodical. The big, extended plays took a backseat in a largely conservative offense that shied away from throwing past the sticks. This year under new play-caller and head coach Mike McCarthy, there has been far more creativity and some more deep shots sprinkled in. However, the investment in quality weapons has been a chronic issue stemming from multiple years of relying on a star receiver along with a supporting cast. 

In 2026, this still holds mostly true, though, depth has improved. Injuries have played their role, too. However, Rodgers has really begun showing his age with his inability to scan the field. NFL.com's Nick Shook wrote on how the team needs to steer clear of their overreliance on the veteran. 

"Week 10 provided us with a reminder of Aaron Rodgers’ age. When plays didn’t work immediately or broke down, it was glaring. When he needed to throw receivers open, he often fell short of the mark," Shook wrote. "The game stands as an example of how this promising Steelers season could go south if they’re forced to heavily rely on Rodgers in the next two months."

Rodgers went 15/29 with 143 passing yards and a touchdown to Metcalf in garbage time. McCarthy hasn't been afraid of letting his quarterback throw for more than 40 times per game in some instances, but lately, this strategy hasn't been working. The Steelers have found success when handing the keys to their running backs, Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle. 

With the receiver room being somewhat of a burden this far and Warren's breakout year, there's no reason why Pittsburgh should be reliant on a 42-year-old who is just games away from hanging up the cleats. The organization has used a Band-Aid approach under center since Ben Roethlisberger retired following the 2021-22 season. With a clear-cut run game and a defense that has mostly been good, typical Steelers football may be the way to go the remainder of the season. 

Rodgers has completed 59.9% of his passes, his lowest mark since becoming a starter. His 6.4 yards per attempt are also his lowest since starting, and he has been a league leader in that category (2011). 

Steelers' Aaron Rodgers

© Brian Fluharty / Imagn Images

Steelers' Aaron Rodgers hands the ball off to Jaylen Warren during a road game against the Patriots in 2025.

The offense needs more splash plays from their quarterback, but based on his age, lack of mobility, inability to lead his pass catchers and so on, he has become a liability. 


Steelers Need To Get Back To Their Dominant Run Game Against Eagles

Warren will have to come back to form and remain there for the offense to win games. His season has been nothing short of amazing, even though he only rushed for 15 yards in Week 10. He's put up 719 yards on the ground and another 320 as a receiver. 

Pittsburgh will head to Philadelphia for a matchup that it has struggled with historically. The Steelers haven't won a game in Philly in decades and the Eagles are coming off a bye week. Thankfully for Pittsburgh, they'll be facing a backup quarterback and a team that has had its fair share of issues. 


#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.