One week ago, the Pittsburgh Steelers were riding a four-game winning streak and sitting in first place in the AFC North. Then came Sunday night in Cincinnati. A 38-18 loss to the Cincinnati Bengals exposed problems on both sides of the ball, and the national conversation around the team changed almost overnight. Pittsburgh is now 6-3 with eight games left, and some of the biggest voices in football are no longer buying the Steelers as a real threat to win the AFC. The latest verdict came from one of the most widely read outlets in the sport.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) talks with Head Coach Mike McCarthy during 2026 training camp in Latrobe, PA.
The Athletic sorted every playoff hopeful into contenders and pretenders on Thursday, and Mike Jones put the Steelers in the pretender group in his AFC breakdown. He gave Pittsburgh credit for having a good roster, but he pointed to two position groups he believes will hold the team back.
"The Steelers have a solid team, but there are fatal flaws, including deficiencies at wide receiver and cornerback," Jones wrote. "Pittsburgh will struggle to win shootouts against quality teams because of an inability to slow explosive foes and keep up with them."
Jones placed the Steelers alongside the Denver Broncos, Cleveland Browns and New England Patriots in the pretender group. The four AFC teams he named as contenders were the Buffalo Bills, Kansas City Chiefs, Jacksonville Jaguars and the Bengals, the same team that just ran Pittsburgh off the field.
This is not the first time the Steelers have heard the label this month. CBS Sports also tagged them with a harsh pretender label when they were 6-2, a take that looked bold at the time. After what happened in Cincinnati, it is a lot harder to argue with.
The wide receiver concern is the easiest one to see. Aaron Rodgers threw for just 143 yards against the Bengals, and the receivers struggled to separate from press coverage for most of the night. DK Metcalf has 35 catches for 432 yards through nine games, according to Steelers.com, which is solid but well short of what the Steelers expected from their top target.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
The cornerback problem showed up just as clearly. Cincinnati's receivers, led by Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins, gave the Pittsburgh secondary problems all night, and Asante Samuel Jr. had one of his toughest nights of the season. His looming problem in coverage has already been a hot topic this week, and there is no easy fix on the current roster. The trade deadline has passed, so any answer will have to come from players already in the building.
Jones' point about shootouts is the part that should worry fans the most. The Steelers have won this year by running the ball with Jaylen Warren and leaning on their defense. That formula works when they get an early lead and can keep the game close and physical. When they fall behind against a team with an elite quarterback, the offense hasn't shown it can throw its way back into the game.
There is still reason for hope. Head Coach Mike McCarthy opened the practice window this week for receivers Michael Pittman Jr. and Roman Wilson. Getting both back would give Rodgers two more reliable targets and take some of the pressure off Metcalf. That alone could change how defenses play this offense.
Steelers Face A Brutal Stretch Of Receiver Matchups
The schedule won't make the cornerback questions go away. Sunday's trip to face the Philadelphia Eagles starts a second half that includes several teams with dangerous receivers. The secondary will have to play much better than it did in Cincinnati for the Steelers to hold onto a playoff spot. Every week from here on out will be a chance to show whether this group can rise to the challenge or whether the doubters were right all along.
Labels like this one don't decide anything in November. One loss turned the conversation, and one big win in Philadelphia could turn it right back. But until the Steelers prove they can keep up with the league's best offenses, SteelerNation should expect to keep hearing the word pretender.
This story was produced with the help of AI and reviewed by SteelerNation editors.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

