Steelers' Jaylen Warren Should Carry More Against Eagles As Aaron Rodgers Struggles (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers' Jaylen Warren Should Carry More Against Eagles As Aaron Rodgers Struggles

Alysa Rubin / Pittsburgh Steelers
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers have spent an awful lot of time trying to get their passing offense going, with very little to show for it. Head Coach Mike McCarthy has repeatedly emphasized the importance of creating more opportunities through the air, but Pittsburgh continues to struggle with the same frustrating issues. Following Sunday's embarrassing loss to the Cincinnati Bengals, one NFL analyst believes the Steelers need to stop making things so complicated and lean into what has actually been working.

Steelers Mike McCarthy

Joseph Maiorana / Imagn Images

Pittsburgh Steelers’ Mike McCarthy stands on the sideline at Paycor Stadium in 2026. SI

NFL analyst Steve Palazzolo believes Pittsburgh needs to make running back Jaylen Warren a bigger priority against the Philadelphia Eagles on Sunday. During a recent episode of the Check The Mic podcast, Palazzolo questioned why the Steelers continue relying so heavily on quarterback Aaron Rodgers when their rushing attack has been considerably more productive.

β€œI think they need to continue to try to run the ball, man. They are one of the most efficient run games in the league, one of the least efficient pass games,” Palazzolo said.

The numbers make his frustration understandable. According to the Steelers' official website, Pittsburgh has thrown the football on 61.7% of its offensive plays this season, the sixth-highest rate in the NFL.

Meanwhile, Warren has rushed for 719 yards on just 126 attempts, averaging an impressive 5.7 yards per carry. Pittsburgh also ranks fourth in explosive rushing rate at 12%, while only 20.1% of its passing plays have gained at least 10 yards, the worst mark in football.

Essentially, the Steelers have developed an offense that is significantly better at running the football while continuing to operate like its greatest strength is throwing it. Sunday's loss to Cincinnati provided an especially frustrating example.

Warren carried the ball seven times for 15 yards, while Rico Dowdle added 26 yards on five attempts. The two combined for just 12 carries, with Cincinnati quickly establishing a lead that forced Pittsburgh into an increasingly predictable passing attack.

Rodgers finished 15 of 29 for 143 yards and two touchdowns, with both scores coming after the Bengals had already built a commanding advantage. Palazzolo wasn't particularly impressed with the quarterback's performance, either.

β€œI don't think Rodgers is playing that well. I know there's some drops. I know DK's having a terrible season, but Rodgers isn't making up for it on the other end either,” Palazzolo said.

His assessment of DK Metcalf is difficult to dismiss. The veteran has caught 35 passes for 432 yards through nine games, despite receiving more targets than anybody else on Pittsburgh's roster.

Rodgers deserves some of the criticism as well. His 59.9% completion percentage is hardly what Pittsburgh envisioned when bringing the four-time MVP back for another season.

Steelers' DK Metcalf

Katie Stratman / Imagn Images

Nov 15, 2026; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf (4) celebrates following a touchdown during the fourth quarter against the Cincinnati Bengals at Paycor Stadium.

The encouraging news is that Philadelphia presents an intriguing opportunity to get Pittsburgh's offense moving in the right direction.

The Eagles rank 29th defensively in rushing expected points added per play, according to recent NFL analytics. Their struggles against the run could give Warren an opportunity to establish himself early, particularly if Pittsburgh avoids falling behind by multiple possessions before halftime.

Warren has already demonstrated what happens when the Steelers consistently give him opportunities. During Pittsburgh's Week 8 victory over the Cleveland Browns, he rushed for 143 yards on 17 carries. The offense produced 200 rushing yards and three touchdowns while Rodgers threw for just 172 yards.

Pittsburgh won that game 27-6.

There is also another interesting component to Warren's production. Of his 719 rushing yards, 301 have come on runs of at least 15 yards. He doesn't need 25 carries to make a difference, but he does need enough opportunities for that explosiveness to become a legitimate part of Pittsburgh's offensive game plan.

The running back has even generated Offensive Player of the Year consideration because of his outstanding season.


Steelers Need Warren To Set The Tone Against Philadelphia

McCarthy shouldn't completely abandon the passing attack against Philadelphia. Rodgers remains capable of making difficult throws, and Pittsburgh will eventually need him to deliver in situations where running the football isn't an option.

However, the coaching staff needs to stop asking the passing offense to carry responsibilities that Warren has already demonstrated he can handle.

Establishing the rushing attack could make Rodgers' job considerably easier. Successful early-down carries create manageable third downs, keep opposing pass rushers from attacking obvious passing situations and open opportunities for play-action.

Pittsburgh has used play-action on just 18.1% of its offensive snaps, one of the lowest rates in the league. Making defenses respect Warren could provide McCarthy with additional opportunities to exploit linebackers stepping toward the line of scrimmage.

The Steelers also need to remain committed to the run when the first couple of carries don't produce huge gains. Nobody is suggesting Pittsburgh should spend an entire afternoon handing the football into an overcrowded defensive front, but abandoning Warren after one unsuccessful series isn't much of a solution.

Rodgers has spent his career proving he can win games with his arm. At 42 years old, he shouldn't need to do that every Sunday.

Pittsburgh already has a running back capable of making the offense dangerous. McCarthy needs to start treating him like its greatest weapon.


#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.