Steelers Get Uncomfortable Nick Herbig Update Ahead Of Eagles Showdown (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers Get Uncomfortable Nick Herbig Update Ahead Of Eagles Showdown

Barry Reeger / Imagn Images
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers have had their eyes on the injury report all week heading into this contest against the Philadelphia Eagles. After an ugly loss to the Cincinnati Bengals, Mike McCarthy's squad knows it needs to bounce back. Unfortunately, the final practice update offered little encouragement about one of Pittsburgh's important defensive contributors.

Steelers Nick Herbig

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Steelers' Nick Herbig during the 2026 season.

Nick Herbig is questionable for Sunday after failing to practice throughout the week, according to Mike DeFabo. That designation leaves the door open, but the lack of participation makes his availability a serious concern. Pittsburgh has to prepare for the possibility of facing Philadelphia without another option in its outside linebacker rotation.

The rest of DeFabo's update offered a more encouraging picture. Michael Pittman Jr., Roman Wilson, DeShon Elliott, Patrick Queen and Gennings Dunker were all full participants Friday despite being listed as questionable. Herbig stood apart from that group for the wrong reason.

"Questionable but full participants on Friday: Michael Pittman Jr., Roman Wilson, DeShon Elliott, Patrick Queen, Gennings Dunker," DeFabo reported. "Questionable and DNP all week: Nick Herbig."

That difference is the story. The Steelers have several players whose practice participation provides some optimism heading into the weekend. Herbig never reached that point, leaving Pittsburgh waiting for a turnaround without the reassurance of seeing him work during the preparation period.

It would be premature to declare him out. Questionable is his designation, and the team has not ruled him out based on the information available Friday. Still, missing every practice is hardly the finish fans wanted to see for a player dealing with hip and rib injuries.

For a defense coming off the Cincinnati loss, the timing is frustrating. Pittsburgh needed more disruption against the Bengals and struggled to make the passing game uncomfortable. Potentially losing another rusher gives the coaching staff less flexibility while it tries to correct those problems.

Herbig's value extends beyond whether he starts. A rotation allows Pittsburgh to bring different rushers into the game and manage the workload on its established players. When one of those options is unavailable, the remaining group has to absorb the responsibility.

Steelers Jack Sawyer

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Steelers rookie edge rusher Jack Sawyer stands on the field at St. Vincent College as the team works out during a 2025 training camp practice in Latrobe, PA.

That puts more attention on TJ Watt and Alex Highsmith, along with how Pittsburgh distributes the snaps behind them. Jack Sawyer could be part of that answer if Herbig cannot go. The exact division of work remains a coaching decision, but the need for reliable execution would become even more important.

Nobody needs to pretend Herbig's absence would decide this game by itself. Pittsburgh still has enough defensive talent to make Philadelphia work for its yards. However, the Steelers would much rather enter a road matchup with their full collection of pass rushers available.

There is an encouraging side to Friday's report, too. Full participation from Queen and Elliott gives Pittsburgh something positive to monitor on defense. Their questionable designations still matter, but their practice status presents a different situation from Herbig's week of inactivity.

The same distinction applies to the players returning from injured reserve. Practicing fully is progress, but it does not automatically mean Pittman, Wilson or Dunker will be activated and play Sunday. Pittsburgh still has roster decisions to make before those potential returns become official.


Steelers Face Alarming Herbig Uncertainty Before Eagles Matchup

For McCarthy, preparation has to account for either outcome. The defense cannot build its plan around assuming Herbig will suddenly be available. If he does play, Pittsburgh gains another option; if he does not, the remaining rushers must already understand their responsibilities.

Herbig could still avoid the inactive list, but Friday supplied no practice evidence to make that feel likely. Until his status changes, fans have reason to worry that Pittsburgh's bounce-back attempt could come without him. That would put the focus on depth at a time when this defense needs a stronger response.


How concerned are you about Herbig potentially missing Sunday? Share your Pittsburgh Steelers thoughts on X with @anthonyghalkias, and follow for more Steelers injury updates, game coverage and roster discussion.

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.