The Pittsburgh Steelers have been entangled with a saga regarding quarterback Aaron Rodgers all offseason. What began as whispers of mutual interest quickly evolved into one of the most polarizing storylines in football. If it’s not going to be Rodgers, many believe the Steelers are seriously in trouble for the 2025 season, as the team remains without a clear long-term answer at quarterback. Rodgers has stated the holdup in his decision involves serious personal issues he's working through, but until now, he hasn't provided much clarity.
Frank Franklin II / ap photo
Former New York Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers nods to acknowledge someone speaking in his direction.
Rodgers attempted to shut down the speculation nearly two months ago during an appearance on The Pat McAfee Show, insisting that rumors about his future were being blown out of proportion. However, fans and insiders remained skeptical, especially as the Steelers passed on other quarterback opportunities while seemingly keeping the door open for Rodgers. The situation grew even murkier this week when Rodgers made a high-profile appearance on The Joe Rogan Experience, reigniting speculation with a comment that many believe may have unintentionally revealed more than he meant to.
Near the end of the interview, while discussing alternative medicine and personal health philosophies, Rodgers appeared to touch on deeply personal matters that may be at the core of his ongoing indecision. Though he didn't directly mention the Steelers or his playing future, Rodgers' tone shifted noticeably when referencing the emotional weight he’s been carrying and the mental clarity he’s seeking.
"I've figured it out during the last year, when I've been in the weeds with these people who are close to me that have cancer, that innovation is frowned upon," Rodgers said. "People who are doing it are getting fu**ing raided, hit with lawsuits, and shut down. You gotta be real quiet if you're helping people on the down low, because that’s one of their moneymakers."
For Steelers fans desperate for answers, the moment felt like a rare glimpse into the private struggles holding up one of the biggest decisions in recent franchise history. This doesn’t necessarily mean these are the exact reasons Rodgers was referring to, but he did make one thing very clear: he is not trying to hold the Steelers hostage.
ESPN
Steelers' Ben Roethlisberger meets with former Packers QB Aaron Rodgers before a home game.
At 41 years old, he is a veteran quarterback with nothing left to prove, simply trying to decide if he still has the desire and capacity to continue playing football. During his recent appearance on Joe Rogan, Rodgers opened up about personal matters he is dealing with, including revealing that people close to him are battling cancer. If that is what is weighing on him, it makes perfect sense why he is approaching this decision with such care and caution.
Rodgers is not trying to mislead anyone. He does not want to disappoint an entire fanbase, and he certainly does not want to make a promise he cannot keep, especially under the intense public spotlight that surrounds his every move. There has been plenty of speculation that Rodgers may already have a handshake deal in place with the Steelers' front office, but nothing has been confirmed.
It is possible that behind the scenes there is already an understanding. If that is the case, it is clear Rodgers wants to be fully ready mentally, emotionally, and physically before making any announcement. A player of his caliber has earned the right to make that decision on his own terms.
Steelers Are At Fault For This Situation, Not Aaron Rodgers
Steelers fans, while understandably frustrated by the ongoing uncertainty at quarterback, should continue to extend grace to Rodgers. He did not create the situation Pittsburgh is currently in. The Steelers' lack of a long-term solution at quarterback is the result of years of instability following Ben Roethlisberger’s retirement.
Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images
Former New York Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers meets with Steelers Head Coach Mike Tomlin after a game in Pittsburgh.
If Rodgers ultimately joins the team, he could bring the leadership and stability the organization has been missing. Until then, he is simply a man facing real-life challenges, trying to make a thoughtful decision about his future. It is easy to forget, especially in the world of football, that players are human beings too. Rodgers is not just making a football decision. He is trying to find peace of mind.
#SteelerNation
