The Pittsburgh Steelers spent the first half of the 2026 season stacking up wins, and they arrived in Cincinnati on Sunday night tied with the Cincinnati Bengals at 6-2 atop the AFC North. One game later, the picture looks very different. The Bengals rolled to a 38-18 win on Sunday Night Football to take sole possession of first place, and the national media wasted no time questioning whether Pittsburgh's strong start was ever as real as the record suggested.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Pittsburgh Steelers Head Coach Mike McCarthy watches the team work out during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
Pro Football Talk host Mike Florio was one of the loudest voices. Breaking down the game with Chris Simms on Monday's PFT Live show, Florio said the first half alone told the story, calling it a complete shredding of the Steelers. He also admitted he had doubts about Pittsburgh long before Sunday night.
"I thought the Steelers were kind of a fugazi 6-2, like how are they doing this? How do they keep winning these games? And last night was the reckoning," Florio said.
Florio added that the night showed two teams with the same record operating on very different levels. The numbers he cited were hard to argue with. The Bengals piled up 337 yards in the first half, while the Steelers managed just 40. Florio said the 24-0 halftime score was actually generous to Pittsburgh given how lopsided the half was.
It was a jarring result for a team that arrived in Cincinnati riding a four-game winning streak and coming off its bye week. The Steelers ran only three offensive plays in the first quarter, and the Bengals had already taken control by the time Pittsburgh found any rhythm. The two late touchdowns made the final score look closer than the game ever felt.
Simms took it a step further and questioned how much talent the Steelers really have. He said that outside of their pass rushers, Pittsburgh's defense doesn't have many players who stand out, and that the team looked outclassed by Cincinnati's elite players. On offense, he pointed to a lack of playmakers, especially with Roman Wilson out of the lineup.
That's where Simms made his boldest claim of the segment, about the Steelers' top receiver, DK Metcalf.
"DK Metcalf shows up like one play a game. It's definitely fallen off with him. He's not nearly the same. I would bet you this will be his last year in Pittsburgh if you made me bet there," Simms said.
It's not the first time Metcalf's future has come up this month. SteelerNation has covered several questions about his role, including news about his future in Pittsburgh. Simms' comments will only add to that conversation, especially after a game in which Aaron Rodgers and the passing game struggled to find answers against Cincinnati's man coverage.

Kirby Lee / Imagn Images
DK Metcalf on the field for the Steelers during the 2026 season.
The PFT duo also took a closer look at Pittsburgh's schedule. They pointed to recent wins over the Colts, the Buccaneers and the Saints, and said Pittsburgh's most impressive victory was a home win over the Browns. Their point was simple: when Pittsburgh faces a team that is elite on one side of the ball, it has trouble keeping up.
On the other side, Florio and Simms couldn't say enough about Joe Burrow. Florio noted Burrow now has five straight games with four or more total touchdowns, putting him in rare company. Simms compared Burrow's current run to some of the greatest quarterback seasons in NFL history.
Steelers Now Chase The Bengals In The AFC North
The loss drops Pittsburgh to 6-3, one game behind Cincinnati at 7-2. With the Bengals holding the split and playing at a high level, the Steelers can't afford many more slips. Head Coach Mike McCarthy made it clear after the game that he has real worries about where his team stands.
The Steelers head to Philadelphia in Week 11 with a chance to quiet the critics. A strong showing would go a long way toward proving Sunday night was one bad game and not, as Florio put it, a reckoning.
SteelerNation, do you agree with Florio and Simms, or was Sunday night just one bad game?
This story was produced with the help of AI and reviewed by SteelerNation editors.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

