Steelers Fan Stephen A. Smith Delivers Brutal Breakdown Of Bengals Loss (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers Fan Stephen A. Smith Delivers Brutal Breakdown Of Bengals Loss

Scott Galvin / Imagn Images
author image

The Pittsburgh Steelers don't have many bigger fans on national television than Stephen A. Smith, which made his reaction to Sunday night's loss even harder to hear. The Cincinnati Bengals beat Pittsburgh 38-18 to take sole possession of first place in the AFC North, and the ESPN star opened Monday's show by walking through the game number by number. By the time he was finished, there wasn't much left to defend.

Steelers' Aaron Rodgers and Mike McCarthy

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) and Head Coach Mike McCarthy (right) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.

The First Take segment started with a bigger question: are the Bengals now the team to beat in the AFC? Former Cowboys receiver Michael Irvin said no. He pointed out that Cincinnati's seven wins came against the Buccaneers, Texans, Dolphins, Ravens, Titans, Falcons and Steelers, and that none of the AFC's heavyweights were on that list. Smith questioned it too, but for a different reason. He said the Bengals' defense has improved enough that the real obstacles are the other contenders, like the Jaguars, Bills, Chiefs and Broncos.

Then Smith turned to the team he roots for, and he didn't hold back.

"I was afraid this was going to happen because ... we all know that I'm a Pittsburgh Steeler fan. I want to put things into perspective about how God-awful the Pittsburgh Steelers were yesterday," Smith said.

Smith then ran through the numbers. He said that at one point in the game, Cincinnati held a 423-29 edge in total offense, along with 363 net passing yards to Pittsburgh's minus-three. He noted that Aaron Rodgers missed on his first eight passes and didn't complete one until about four minutes remained in the first half. Through three quarters, Smith said, the Steelers ran 32 plays for 23 yards.

He also came to the defense of running back Jaylen Warren, saying his quiet night wasn't his fault because the Steelers dug a hole they could never climb out of. Smith put most of the blame on a defense that had looked so good during the team's four-game winning streak.

"... This defense ... didn't show up. Spent time this year fooling us into thinking they can handle their business against an elite offense and then they got humbled like h**l last night," Smith said.

Smith wrapped it up by saying there are levels to this league, and right now the Steelers aren't on Cincinnati's level. He added that former Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin seemed to be saying the same thing during NBC's coverage, when he had his own sharp take on his old team.

Steelers' Jaylen Warren

Scott Galvin / Imagn Images

Jaylen Warren on the field for the Steelers during the 2026 season.

Smith has never hidden his Steelers fandom on the show, and he has never been shy about criticizing them when they struggle. This time, the numbers left him with nothing to argue. The show also noted that Joe Burrow became just the third player in NFL history to throw 20 touchdown passes in a five-game span, joining Tom Brady and Peyton Manning. Ja'Marr Chase did plenty of the damage on Sunday, finishing with 11 catches for 231 yards.

For a Steelers team that hadn't lost in more than five weeks, it was a rude reminder of how quickly things can change in the AFC North.


Steelers' Offense Needs Answers Before Philadelphia

As bad as the defense looked, Smith's numbers point just as hard at the offense. Rodgers has already called out his receivers for failing to win against Cincinnati's coverage, and his postgame comments raised questions about the play-calling under Head Coach Mike McCarthy. Whatever the fix is, it needs to come quickly. The Steelers can't afford another week where the offense goes three quarters without moving the ball, especially with the division lead now in Cincinnati's hands.

The Steelers are 6-3 and one game behind the Bengals heading into a Week 11 trip to Philadelphia. A bounce-back win would quiet some of the noise. Another flat performance would give Smith and every other national critic plenty more to say. SteelerNation will find out soon which version of this team shows up.


This story was produced with the help of AI and reviewed by SteelerNation editors.

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.