The Pittsburgh Steelers have spent the past several years renting quarterbacks while searching for somebody worth making a long-term investment in. The organization currently has four signal-callers on its roster, which is particularly unusual for a franchise that spent nearly two decades knowing exactly who would be under center every Sunday. With another offseason of quarterback uncertainty approaching, the Steelers will eventually have to decide whether they are genuinely committed to developing their own franchise quarterback. One longtime Pittsburgh insider is already dreading the possibility of history repeating itself in 2027.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Mason Rudolph (2) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
Reporter Ray Fittipaldo appeared on 93.7 The Fan Wednesday morning and discussed the possibility of veteran quarterback Mason Rudolph becoming Pittsburgh's starter next season. Fittipaldo made his feelings about that scenario abundantly clear.
“God, I hope it's not Mason. And nothing against Mason, man. But you just can't go down that road. Like, you got to find out about these guys sooner rather than later,” Fittipaldo said.
Rudolph is currently serving as the primary backup to Aaron Rodgers, who announced in May that the 2026 campaign would be his final NFL season. Rudolph's two-year contract also expires after this season, meaning Pittsburgh would need to re-sign him to have him available in 2027.
The possibility of Rudolph eventually taking over gained some traction during Sunday night's loss to the Cincinnati Bengals. The NBC broadcast offered some interesting insight into Pittsburgh's quarterback plans, including the possibility of Head Coach Mike McCarthy relying on quarterbacks already inside the building next season.
Fittipaldo understands why Rudolph remains valuable to Pittsburgh in 2026. However, he believes the organization would be making a mistake by extending that arrangement into another season with Rudolph as the starter.
“He's the backup now. He's the guy who's going to go in for Rodgers if that does happen. But that would be really disappointing for me if they went down the road of another veteran instead of finding out about one of these young guys they've been trying to bring along here,” Fittipaldo added.
Pittsburgh deserves credit for retaining both Will Howard and Drew Allar on its initial 53-man roster. General Manager Omar Khan sacrificed a roster spot that could have been used elsewhere to protect both developmental quarterbacks.
Eventually, though, protecting young quarterbacks needs to involve more than protecting them from seeing an actual NFL defense.

Karl Roser / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers QBs Aaron Rodgers, Will Howard, Mason Rudolph, and Drew Allar throw the ball in the 2026 offseason.
Howard, the 185th overall selection in the 2025 NFL Draft, missed his rookie preseason because of a hand injury. The former Ohio State national champion finally received his first exhibition opportunities this summer, producing some encouraging moments alongside several costly mistakes.
Allar arrived this offseason as the 76th overall selection in the 2026 NFL Draft. The former Penn State standout threw for 153 yards and two touchdowns while adding another score on the ground during Pittsburgh's preseason opener against the Green Bay Packers.
Neither performance provided enough evidence to declare Pittsburgh's quarterback search over. Both players remain behind Rudolph on the depth chart, and neither has appeared in a regular-season game.
McCarthy was brought to Pittsburgh with a reputation for developing quarterbacks. Giving him an opportunity to build an offense around one of those younger players should be considerably more appealing than asking him to squeeze another season out of a veteran whose capabilities are already relatively well established.
Rudolph certainly deserves appreciation for what he has provided Pittsburgh. His three consecutive victories at the end of the 2023 regular season helped rescue a playoff berth, and having somebody with his experience available behind Rodgers makes sense for a team trying to win immediately.
That doesn't mean he should become the organization's next long-term experiment.
Steelers Need To Find Out What They Have In Howard And Allar
Pittsburgh's obsession with remaining competitive every season has occasionally come at the expense of finding out whether it has the pieces necessary to become a championship contender. Starting Rudolph in 2027 might provide a higher immediate floor, but what exactly would the organization learn from another season of watching him play?
The Steelers shouldn't hand Howard or Allar the starting job simply because they're younger. If McCarthy believes neither player is capable of becoming a franchise quarterback, Khan needs to aggressively explore the 2027 NFL Draft.
However, allowing another veteran to occupy the starting position without seriously evaluating those young quarterbacks would defeat much of the purpose of keeping both around this season.
Pittsburgh has spent years looking for its next franchise quarterback. At some point, the organization has to stop treating the position like a temporary staffing assignment.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

