Richard Sherman Calls Steelers "Fool's Gold" After 38-18 Loss To Bengals (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Richard Sherman Calls Steelers "Fool's Gold" After 38-18 Loss To Bengals

Ron Chenoy / Imagn Images
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers are still in the playoff picture, but Richard Sherman is not buying what their record is selling. After Pittsburgh's 38-18 loss to the Cincinnati Bengals, the former cornerback delivered a blunt assessment of a team that entered the game with plenty of confidence. His concern goes beyond one ugly Sunday night.

Steelers Mike McCarthy Omar Khan

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Pittsburgh Steelers Head Coach Mike McCarthy stands alongside General Manager Omar Khan as the two watch the team practice during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.

Sherman believes the Steelers have benefited from their schedule while leaning on a running game that has covered for other shortcomings. That argument will frustrate fans who watched Pittsburgh win four straight before Cincinnati. However, getting overwhelmed by a divisional opponent gave critics an opening, and Sherman certainly took it.

On The Richard Sherman Podcast, the former All-Pro questioned Pittsburgh's passing offense and a defense loaded with recognizable names. He praised Jaylen Warren, but his evaluation became much less complimentary when discussing DK Metcalf, Aaron Rodgers and the secondary. Sherman sees weaknesses that he believes will eventually determine how this season ends.

"The Pittsburgh Steelers are fool's gold who have benefited from a favorable schedule," Sherman said. "They have won games and grinded it out on the ground. Jaylen Warren is having a spectacular impact on this offense, but DK Metcalf is not, and he's getting paid a lot of money. You expect him to have a bigger season than he has had. Aaron Rodgers hasn't had his best season, obviously, and he's older."

That is a tough assessment, but Sherman did identify the player who has consistently given Pittsburgh an offensive spark. Warren's impact has helped the Steelers win games without needing the passing attack to carry everything. The problem comes when the running game cannot provide that cushion and Rodgers needs to generate answers.

Against Cincinnati, those answers arrived far too late. Rodgers completed 15 of 29 attempts for 143 yards, two touchdowns and no interceptions. Pittsburgh needed more production while the game was competitive, and the offense never consistently matched the challenge on the other sideline.

Metcalf's role adds another layer to the frustration. The expectations attached to him are considerably higher than simply being another available target. Sherman argued that his production has not matched those expectations, particularly given the money Pittsburgh has committed to the receiver.

Steelers Mike McCarthy and Aaron Rodgers

Barry Reeger / Imagn Images

Pittsburgh Steelers’ Mike McCarthy talks with Aaron Rodgers during training camp at Saint Vincent College in 2026.

Still, the most concerning part of Sherman's evaluation involved the defense. A struggling offense can leave a defense in difficult situations, but Pittsburgh also failed to disrupt Cincinnati enough to create opportunities. Joe Burrow threw for 409 yards and four touchdowns without an interception, while Ja'Marr Chase finished with 231 receiving yards.

"They got the 30th-ranked pass defense in terms of yards," Sherman said. "With all the guys and names they got, when their front four, Cam Heyward, Highsmith, TJ Watt, don't get home, this defense gets exposed. And I think that will be their demise this season."

Sherman's criticism puts the spotlight on Cameron Heyward, Alex Highsmith and TJ Watt, but the point reaches beyond their individual production. He is questioning whether Pittsburgh can survive when its rush does not dictate the game. That is a fair concern after watching Cincinnati repeatedly find space through the air.


Steelers Must Prove Sherman's Fool's Gold Verdict Is Premature

There is a difference between identifying weaknesses and deciding those weaknesses will end a season. Sherman has made his prediction, but Pittsburgh still has opportunities to change the conversation. A better performance next week would help, although one win would not automatically answer everything Cincinnati exposed.

The Steelers need a passing attack that can contribute before desperation takes over. They also need coverage and pressure to work together, rather than expecting the rush to rescue every difficult matchup. Those are practical football problems that require better execution and adjustments.


Do you agree with Sherman's assessment, or is he overlooking what Pittsburgh can become? Share your Pittsburgh Steelers takes on X with @anthonyghalkias, and follow for more Steelers coverage, game reactions and roster discussion.

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.