Steelers' DK Metcalf Has NFL's Worst Catch Rate Through Nine Games (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers' DK Metcalf Has NFL's Worst Catch Rate Through Nine Games

Katie Stratman / Imagn Images
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers went into their bye week saying the offense needed to run through their highest-paid receiver. Two games later, the numbers say that plan is not working. After a 38-18 loss in Cincinnati where the passing game didn't get going until the game was out of reach, one of the most-followed analysts in football put out a stat line that is hard for any Steelers fan to look at. It shows just how big the problem has become at the top of the receiver room.

Steelers' DK Metcalf

Ken Blaze / Imagn Images

Steelers WR DK Metcalf makes a catch after getting past Browns safety Grant Delpit in the second half of a 2026 Week 3 matchup.

Warren Sharp of Sharp Football Analysis broke down DK Metcalf's season in a post on X Tuesday afternoon. The post had been viewed more than 240,000 times by Wednesday morning.

"DK Metcalf this season (70 targets in 9 games): 50% catch rate, worst in NFL. 14.6% drop rate, #2 highest of 96 pass catchers," Sharp wrote.

Sharp added one more number that might be the most worrying of all. Metcalf's success rate on targets sits at 35.7%, which ranks 93rd out of the 96 pass catchers in his comparison. In simple terms, when the ball goes Metcalf's way, the Steelers are rarely getting the result they want from the play.

The catch rate is the headline. Through nine games, Metcalf has 35 catches on 70 targets, meaning half of the balls thrown his way have fallen incomplete. For a receiver who is supposed to be the No. 1 option, that is a tough number to defend. Some of those incompletions are on the quarterback, and some come on deep shots that are low-percentage throws by design. But the drop rate is all on the receiver, and only one pass catcher in Sharp's group has a higher one.

Sunday night in Cincinnati followed the same pattern. Metcalf did score a touchdown, but his production came late, after the Cincinnati Bengals had already taken control of the game. Aaron Rodgers called out his receivers after the loss, saying Cincinnati played a lot of press and man coverage and Pittsburgh didn't make them pay for it.

Steelers' DK Metcalf and Michael Pittman Jr.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)

Pittsburgh Steelers star wide receivers DK Metcalf (4) and Michael Pittman Jr. (11) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.

Sharp also pointed out the gap between what the Steelers said and what has happened on the field. In a follow-up post, he noted that Pittsburgh came out of the bye week talking about getting Metcalf more involved. Head Coach Mike McCarthy took responsibility for Metcalf's quiet season at the time, and he explained his thinking during a bye week press conference.

"I look at it as a play-caller. Am I putting DK in position to be successful? That's where I always start anything that I'm looking at offensively," McCarthy said.

The Steelers have tried. Metcalf has more targets than anyone on the roster, and Matt Williamson of Steelers.com noted last week that he runs a route on 99.4% of dropbacks, the highest rate in the league. Volume isn't the issue. The issue is what happens once the ball is in the air.

That is a big reason the criticism has piled up this week. A former Steelers coach called out Metcalf's habits during games on Tuesday, and others have asked whether Rodgers is forcing too many throws his way instead of spreading the ball around to open targets.


Steelers' Passing Game Needs A Fix Before Philadelphia

The contract makes all of this louder. Pittsburgh traded a second-round pick to the Seattle Seahawks to get Metcalf and then signed him to a $132 million extension. When a team pays a receiver like a star, it expects him to win the contested catches and finish the plays that matter. So far in 2026, the numbers say that isn't happening often enough.

There is still time to turn it around. Help could be on the way, with Roman Wilson and Michael Pittman Jr. eligible to return to practice, which would give Rodgers more options and could take some attention off Metcalf. But the Steelers visit the Philadelphia Eagles on Sunday, and they need their top receiver to look like one. SteelerNation will be watching closely to see whether Metcalf can start changing these numbers in a hostile road environment.


This story was produced with the help of AI and reviewed by SteelerNation editors.

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.