The Pittsburgh Steelers are getting another reminder that their biggest offensive problem might surrounding the player they expected to lead the receiving corps. DK Metcalf was brought to Pittsburgh to become Aaron Rodgers' top target and give the offense a legitimate No. 1 wide receiver. Instead, his disappointing production has become a growing concern.

Karl Roser / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' DK Metcalf celebrates after gaining a first down during a road game against the Baltimore Ravens in 2025.
Former Steelers cornerback Joe Haden is making it clear that the criticism is about more than what people are saying outside the building. Speaking on the Deebo & Joe podcast, Haden offered a blunt assessment of Metcalf's struggles, pointing to his inability to consistently separate from defensive backs and his problems finishing opportunities when the football reaches him.
"There's no separation when you running fade balls sometimes and the balls hitting you in the hands on crossers, this has nothing to do with media, this has everything to do with the field of play, you are the eighth highest paid receiver in the NFL, I mean father time is undefeated," Haden said. "I know it's not us that's dropping the ball, you gonna have to get more separation."
That is a particularly notable criticism coming from someone who spent years competing against some of the best receivers in the NFL. Haden understands what it takes to get open at this level, and his argument is that Metcalf's struggles cannot simply be dismissed as outside noise. The numbers certainly give Haden a reason to be concerned.
Through nine games, Metcalf has been targeted 70 times and has caught just 35 passes, giving him a 50% catch rate. That is the worst mark in the NFL. His 14.6% drop rate is the second highest among 96 qualifying pass catchers, while his 35.7% success rate on targets ranks 93rd out of 96.
Those are difficult numbers to overlook for a receiver making the kind of money Metcalf is earning. Pittsburgh did not acquire him to be an occasional deep threat or someone who disappears for stretches of games. The Steelers invested heavily in him because they believed he could consistently win against opposing cornerbacks and make life easier for Rodgers. Instead, the offense has struggled to get consistent production from its highest-profile receiver.
Haden's comments also highlight an important distinction. Metcalf can point to outside criticism and the attention surrounding his performance, but the former Steelers defensive back believes the bigger issue is what happens between the lines. When a receiver is struggling to separate on routes and is not consistently making catches on passes that reach his hands, the conversation naturally shifts toward his actual performance.
There is only so much a player can blame on the media when the production is not there. The concerning part for Pittsburgh is that this has not been a problem isolated to one bad afternoon. Metcalf has struggled to establish consistency throughout the season, and the numbers suggest that the Steelers are not getting the return they expected when they made him one of the highest paid receivers in football.

Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images
Steelers' DK Metcalf drops a pass during a win over the Atlanta Falcons to open up the 2026 season at home.
His 50% catch rate is especially alarming when compared with other prominent receivers around the league. Haden also discussed how players such as Tee Higgins and Zay Flowers have been much more productive despite receiving similar or comparable target volume.
Flowers, for example, has turned 70 targets into 49 receptions, 688 yards and three touchdowns. Metcalf has 35 catches for 432 yards and two touchdowns on the same number of targets. That comparison makes the gap in production difficult to ignore.
There is still plenty of time for Metcalf to turn his season around, and Pittsburgh needs him to do exactly that, and quickly. The Steelers cannot expect Rodgers to consistently carry the passing offense if the receiver expected to be his top option continues struggling to create separation and finish catches. Metcalf has the physical ability and experience to be a major weapon, but those qualities need to show up on Sundays.
Haden's comments are particularly interesting because he is not simply calling out Metcalf for having a few bad games. He is questioning whether the receiver is still able to consistently do the things that made him such a dangerous player earlier in his career. Father Time eventually catches up with every athlete, as Haden pointed out, but Metcalf still has an opportunity to prove that his best football is not behind him.
Steelers Are Paying Top Dollar For Production They Aren't Getting From Metcalf
For the Steelers, that needs to happen sooner rather than later. They made a major investment in Metcalf expecting him to elevate the offense, and the current production is nowhere near what that investment should bring. Outside criticism is not going away until the results change, and Haden's assessment reflects a growing frustration with what Pittsburgh is getting from its most expensive receiver.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

