The Pittsburgh Steelers and Philadelphia Eagles meet on Sunday with two very different seasons going. The Steelers are trying to bounce back from a lopsided loss in Cincinnati, while the Eagles have lost seven straight games and are already looking ahead. But a look at the past decade tells a different story about which franchise has been more successful when it matters most. One Pittsburgh columnist believes the difference starts at the top of each organization, and he made it clear which approach he prefers.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Steelers Team President Art Rooney II walks the sideline as the team warms up before a 2022 preseason game at Acrisure Stadium.
Joe Starkey compared the two franchises in his latest Cup of Joe column for TribLive on Friday. Starkey, who also hosts a midday show on 93.7 The Fan, said Pennsylvania's two NFL teams run their businesses in very different ways.
"One state. Two teams. Two very different ways of conducting business. I prefer the Philadelphia Eagles' method, thank you," Starkey wrote.
The numbers he used are hard to ignore. Since the start of the 2017 season, the Eagles have won 10 playoff games and played in two Super Bowls, winning one. The Steelers have not won a playoff game in that span, going 0-6 with an average margin of defeat of 14.5 points. Starkey noted that if not for a touchdown with one second left against the Jacksonville Jaguars in 2017, all six of those losses would have come by double digits.
Starkey pointed to how each team is built. He described the Eagles under owner Jeffrey Lurie as an organization driven by its general manager, one that treats a rare losing season as a chance to reset and is willing to move on from coaches and key players. The Steelers under Art Rooney II, he wrote, have been driven by their head coaches and have worked to protect a streak of 22 straight seasons without a losing record.
That streak has become the franchise's calling card, but Starkey argued it has come at a cost. He noted that losing seasons are what brought Terry Bradshaw and Ben Roethlisberger to Pittsburgh, and those two quarterbacks were behind all six of the Steelers' Super Bowl titles.
Starkey also brought up a comment Rooney made after Mike Tomlin left following last season's playoff loss, when the team president was asked about the idea of a full rebuild.
"(I'm) not sure why you waste a year of your life not trying to contend," Rooney said.
The Eagles have taken the opposite approach. Starkey pointed out that Philadelphia very publicly tanked in 2020 and benefited from it right away and for years after. This season, once it was clear the team was not going to contend, the Eagles traded center Cam Jurgens and defensive lineman Jordan Davis for a first-round pick and two second-round picks.

Chuck Cook / Imagn Images
Steelers' Art Rooney II alongside former Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin during a practice.
Philadelphia also sent receiver A.J. Brown to the New England Patriots for a first-round pick. According to Starkey, Eagles general manager Howie Roseman now has 10 picks in the first three rounds over the next three years, and he may not be finished.
The Eagles' coaching situation could change too. Starkey wrote that it is no sure bet head coach Nick Sirianni will be retained, and the futures of quarterback Jalen Hurts and running back Saquon Barkley remain to be seen. In Philadelphia, he argued, those kinds of moves are simply accepted as part of the process.
The Steelers went in a different direction this year. They hired Mike McCarthy to replace Tomlin and kept the focus on winning now, with a veteran roster built around quarterback Aaron Rodgers.
Steelers Can Make A Statement Against A Rebuilding Eagles Team
Sunday's game adds an interesting twist to the debate. The Eagles are 2-7 and have won 11 straight home games against the Steelers, according to Steelers.com. Beating a team in the middle of a reset would end that long losing streak in Philadelphia.
A win would not settle the bigger question Starkey raised, though. That answer only comes in January. Until the Steelers win a playoff game again, the comparison to the Eagles is not going away, and SteelerNation will keep hearing about it.
This story was produced with the help of AI and reviewed by SteelerNation editors.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

