The Pittsburgh Steelers had two weeks to get ready for the biggest game of their season so far, a Sunday night showdown with the Cincinnati Bengals for first place in the AFC North. What they delivered instead was a 38-18 loss that was never competitive after the first quarter. The final score bothered plenty of people. For one former NFL head coach on the NBC set, though, the scoreboard wasn't the most troubling part of the night.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Pittsburgh Steelers Defensive Coordinator Patrick Graham during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
Jason Garrett, the former Dallas Cowboys head coach who now works as an analyst for NBC, broke down the game with Devin McCourty and Jac Collinsworth on the NBC postgame show. The crew started with the X's and O's. Cincinnati played man coverage, loaded the box to take away Jaylen Warren and the run game, and dared Pittsburgh's receivers to win on the outside. They never did.
The crew also pointed out that the Steelers' veterans seemed to know exactly how Cincinnati beat them, and warned that more opponents will copy that plan of loading up against the run and daring Pittsburgh to win through the air. Then Garrett brought up a Steelers veteran's postgame answer about what hurt the most: playing like this in a division game on the road. Garrett agreed, and said the way Pittsburgh lost bothered him more than the loss itself.
"You want to fight, scratch, claw, and if you lose at the end ... that's one thing. But there was no fight tonight," Garrett said.
Garrett acknowledged that much of it came down to execution on both sides of the ball. When an opponent is controlling the clock on offense and the other team can't answer, he explained, a lot of the fight naturally drains out of a game. Still, he made it clear that wasn't an excuse for how Pittsburgh looked in such a big spot.
He followed that with an even sharper line about the moment the Steelers let slip away.
"This is not the kind of game you want to play against a divisional opponent on a big night ... They didn't show up," Garrett said.
It's hard to argue with him. The Steelers ran just three offensive plays in the first quarter, trailed 24-0 at halftime and were down 31-3 before two late touchdowns made the final score look more respectable. Joe Burrow threw for more than 400 yards, and Ja'Marr Chase finished with 231 receiving yards. Meanwhile, a Pittsburgh run game that had helped carry the offense during its four-game winning streak never found its footing, which left the Steelers with no way to slow the game down.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Pittsburgh Steelers captain Cam Heyward during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
Garrett wasn't the only one on the NBC crew with harsh words. Former Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin, who worked the game for the network, had his own blunt take on what he saw from his old team. And Head Coach Mike McCarthy admitted after the game that the performance was not up to standard for the organization.
The effort question is the one that will sting the most inside the building. A team can live with being outschemed for a night. Being called out for a lack of fight on national television is a different kind of criticism, and it's one this group will have to answer on the field.
Steelers' Locker Room Faces A Gut Check In Philadelphia
The veterans have already started that conversation. Captain Cam Heyward gave a brutally honest verdict after the game, and linebacker Patrick Queen said the defense should have adjusted better once Cincinnati changed its approach.
Now the Steelers have to carry that message into a Week 11 trip to Philadelphia. At 6-3, they are still very much in the playoff picture, but another flat performance would turn one bad night into a real trend. The Eagles will present a very different test than the Bengals did, but the questions about effort will follow this team until it gives a clear answer. SteelerNation will find out soon whether Garrett's words light a fire under this team.
This story was produced with the help of AI and reviewed by SteelerNation editors.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

