Former Steelers OL Willie Colon Says Pay Troy Fautanu 'ASAP' (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Former Steelers OL Willie Colon Says Pay Troy Fautanu 'ASAP'

Alysa Rubin / Pittsburgh Steelers
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers have a big decision coming on one of their young offensive linemen. Troy Fautanu has had an up-and-down first season at left tackle, and the debate over his future has picked up in recent days. Some former Steelers believe the team should wait and see. One former Super Bowl champion who played on the offensive line thinks the answer is already clear, and he wants the front office to act quickly.

Former Steelers OL Willie Colon

USA Today

Former Steelers tackle Willie Colon is introduced at Heinz Field during a ceremony celebrating the Super Bowl XLIII championship team.

Willie Colon made his case for Fautanu on Thursday's episode of In the Locker Room on the Steelers Audio Network. Colon spent eight seasons on the Steelers' offensive line, won a Super Bowl in Pittsburgh and later finished his career with the New York Jets, so he knows exactly what the job requires up front.

"You pay Troy. It makes sense from the standpoint of, at this point, he's starting to be the anchor of your offensive line," Colon said.

Colon pointed out that Fautanu is still young and has plenty of room to grow. He also believes the move to the left side, which caused some growing pains early this season, will pay off next year once Fautanu is fully settled at one position.

"If I was Omar Khan and company, I would start thinking about an extension and getting him together ASAP," Colon added.

That is a very different take from the one Charlie Batch gave earlier this week. Batch questioned whether the Steelers should pick up Fautanu's fifth-year option, noting that T.J. Watt was the last Steelers first-round pick to have his option exercised. Colon is skipping that step entirely and pushing for a long-term deal.

The timing matters. Under the NFL's rules, a drafted player can't sign a contract extension until after his third regular season, which makes this coming offseason the first chance the Steelers will have to work out a new deal with Fautanu. The team also has until next spring to decide on his fifth-year option, which would keep him under contract through the 2028 season. Signing him to an extension first would take that decision off the table and could end up saving money if he keeps improving.

Steelers OT Troy Fautanu

Eric Canha / Imagn Images

Pittsburgh Steelers offensive tackle Troy Fautanu (76) protects quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) against the New England Patriots during the 2026 season.

Fautanu's play has given both sides something to point to. The 2024 first-round pick started his career at right tackle before Head Coach Mike McCarthy moved him to the left side this year. He has had some rough moments, including a tough night in Cincinnati. But he has also been a big part of a line that helped the Steelers win four straight games before the bye.

Fautanu has also had to make up for lost time. The No. 20 overall pick out of Washington played just one game as a rookie in 2024 before a knee injury ended his season, so he still has less than two full seasons of starting experience. Colon's argument is that the Steelers have already seen enough in that time to know what they have.

The move also opened the door for rookie Max Iheanachor to settle in at right tackle. If both players keep developing, the Steelers could have their bookends in place for years. That is exactly the kind of stability Colon wants the team to lock in now.


Steelers Have Several Young Linemen To Pay

Fautanu is not the only young lineman who could be in line for a new deal. Center Zach Frazier and left guard Mason McCormick also came into the league in 2024, which means General Manager Omar Khan will have plenty to sort out this offseason.

McCormick's ankle injury in Cincinnati was also a reminder of how quickly a line can get thin. Locking in the young core early would give the Steelers more cost certainty as the salary cap keeps rising.

Paying Fautanu early would be a bet on his upside rather than his results so far. Colon clearly believes that bet is worth making. SteelerNation will get a better idea over the final eight games of whether Fautanu can prove him right.


This story was produced with the help of AI and reviewed by SteelerNation editors.

#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.