The Pittsburgh Steelers are set for a much different looking era now that Mike Tomlin has walked away from coaching. At 53 years old, the football world is pretty shocked to see that Tomlin is no longer the man leading Pittsburgh. For 19 seasons, Tomlin was a brilliant leader who certainly had some flaws, but he won a Super Bowl early in his tenure. Some argue that championship came with Bill Cowher’s roster and that Tomlin inherited Ben Roethlisberger. Without that foundation, many wonder how different his career might have looked, but that argument can be made for almost any coach who has experienced success or failure.
Al Bello / Getty Images
Steelers Head Coach Mike Tomlin and then-quarterback Ben Roethlisberger celebrate after winning the AFC Championship Game to move onto the Super Bowl.
Tomlin’s legacy is complex and layered. He never had a losing season in nearly two decades, which is remarkably impressive in the NFL and speaks to his consistency, leadership, and ability to manage locker rooms through changing eras. At the same time, he did not win a playoff game after the 2016 season, which has become a major point of criticism among fans and analysts. That contrast between sustained regular season success and postseason disappointment makes evaluating his overall impact more difficult than a simple win-loss record suggests.
Sports analyst Emmanuel Acho recently touched on this complexity while speaking with former NFL receiver T.J. Houshmandzadeh. Acho delivered some harsh truths about Tomlin’s tenure, pointing out areas where expectations may not have been met and questioning how much responsibility falls on the coach versus the roster construction around him. The conversation has sparked renewed debate about how history should remember Tomlin, not just as a great coach, but as one whose career invites real and nuanced discussion.
"Mike Tomlin is a brilliant defensive mind, he's a brilliant motivator, he's a brilliant leader of men, he's a brilliant speaker, he's a brilliant all of those things," Acho said while speaking about Tomlin on his podcast. "But he has never shown you this ability. Mike Tomlin has never shown you the ability to evaluate or develop a quarterback. Ever. Mike Tomlin inherited Ben Roethlisberger. I apologize for this truth that I am about to say. When he had to draft Mason Rudolph, it didn't work. Landry Jones, didn't work. Devlin Duck Hodges, acquired him, didn't work. Josh Dobbs, Tennessee, didn't work. Justin Fields, acquired him, didn't work."
To be fair to Tomlin, Acho is pointing out a lot of project or fringe quarterbacks, guys no one truly had strong faith in. Tomlin was not drafting these players with the expectation that they would develop into franchise starters, but rather as backups behind Roethlisberger who might possibly develop over time.
%202023%20Camp%20Final%20with%20Logos/2L9A6665-544x306.jpg "Steelers Kenny Pickett Mike Tomlin TJ Watt")
Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Former Steelers Head Coach Mike Tomlin looks on as ex-QB Kenny Pickett tries to avoid a sack from TJ Watt during training camp in Latrobe, PA.
It feels a bit unfair, especially when mentioning someone like Devlin “Duck” Hodges. That said, there is still some truth to what Acho is articulating.
"So he [Mike Tomlin] said, you know what? I am not good at identifying talent, let me just acquire veterans," Acho said. "Russell Wilson, Aaron Rodgers, Mike Tomlin in his 19 year coaching career has never, ever, shown the ability to identify and develop the best position."
Russell Wilson struggled so badly with the Denver Broncos that the team paid him $39 million in cash in 2024 as part of his remaining guaranteed salary, while also absorbing a massive $85 million total salary cap hit across 2024 and 2025 just to move on from him.
Mike Tomlin's Legacy With The Steelers Remains Complex
In that context, it is actually fairly impressive what Tomlin was able to get out of Wilson compared to how things unfolded in Denver. That perspective matters when evaluating Tomlin’s ability to maximize what he had to work with.
Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images
Steelers quarterback Russell Wilson gives Head Coach Mike Tomlin a high-five as the team participates in a 2024 regular season game at Acrisure Stadium in Pittsburgh, PA.
While the failure of Kenny Pickett is arguably the biggest blemish on Tomlin’s recent résumé, it is notable that Acho did not even highlight that point. Overall, Tomlin’s legacy remains complicated, but it is difficult to deny that he consistently got more out of his rosters than many coaches would have.
Please feel free to share your Steelers takes with me on X @anthonyghalkias and follow me. I will respond!
#SteelerNation