The Pittsburgh Steelers have invested a substantial amount of draft capital in their defensive front over the past several years. The expectation was that Pittsburgh would eventually develop a group capable of making life considerably easier for its linebackers. Sunday's embarrassing 38-18 loss to the Cincinnati Bengals gave former Steelers linebacker James Harrison plenty of material for his latest film breakdown. Interestingly enough, Harrison came away impressed with one of Pittsburgh's younger defensive linemen while questioning whether another was preventing his teammates from playing to their potential.

YouTube / Deebo & Joe
James Harrison and Joe Haden speak on their podcast Deebo & Joe.
During Monday's episode of the Deebo & Joe podcast, Harrison repeatedly criticized fourth-year defensive lineman Keeanu Benton for transitioning into his pass rush before establishing whether Cincinnati was running the football. Harrison believed Benton's eagerness to penetrate the offensive front compromised his responsibilities against the run.
“Why did that happen? Because my guy 95, he went and converted his rush into a pass rush before he let it declare if it was run or not,” Harrison said.
Cincinnati actually finished Sunday with just 78 rushing yards on 20 attempts. Quarterback Joe Burrow inflicted considerably more damage through the air, throwing for 409 yards and four touchdowns. Harrison's criticism, however, was less about the collective rushing numbers and more about the individual mistakes that can prevent a defense from functioning properly.
Harrison found a much more encouraging example of defensive line play while watching second-year nose tackle Yahya Black defend a rushing attempt by Bengals running back Chase Brown.
“Brown gets the one yard. Reason he only get one, 94 sitting in there. He whoops the center. He pushes him back,” Harrison said.
The difference in Harrison's assessment of the two defensive linemen was particularly noticeable. Black was creating disruption while remaining committed to his responsibilities. Benton, according to Harrison, was occasionally creating disruption in the wrong direction.
There is nothing inherently wrong with a defensive lineman aggressively attacking the backfield. Pittsburgh needs more interior pass-rush production, especially after recording just one sack against Burrow on Sunday. However, guessing incorrectly can leave a rather expensive piece of real estate available for an opposing running back.
Harrison eventually explained how Benton's inconsistency could be affecting inside linebacker Payton Wilson.
“94 in there. He eating up double teams. Like, he's doing what he got to do. But at the same time, I need P-Dub to shoot the gap. But P-Dub can't really shoot that gap because he's trying to figure out if 95 going to play peekaboo again,” Harrison said.
Wilson recorded a team-high 17 tackles against Cincinnati, but Harrison identified something the box score couldn't necessarily explain. A linebacker who isn't entirely sure what the defensive linemen in front of him are going to do has to spend valuable time processing information before attacking the football.

Jordan Perez / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' Patrick Queen and Cam Heyward combine for a tackle during a horrible loss to the Bengals in 2026.
Wilson's speed is arguably his greatest asset. Pittsburgh selected him 98th overall in the 2024 NFL Draft because of his ability to cover ground and make plays that many linebackers simply cannot. Asking Wilson to hesitate because he doesn't trust the integrity of the defensive front essentially takes away one of the reasons Pittsburgh drafted him.
Black's emergence has been particularly encouraging because he understands the value of doing work that rarely earns individual recognition. Occupying two offensive linemen may not get him a tackle, but it can give Wilson or Patrick Queen a relatively clean path to the running back.
Harrison has previously expressed concerns about Benton's performance. The fact that similar issues are still catching his attention in November should be frustrating for a player now in his fourth professional season.
Steelers Need More Discipline From Benton As Black Continues Developing
Defensive Coordinator Patrick Graham shouldn't discourage Benton from utilizing his pass-rushing ability. The former Wisconsin standout recorded 5.5 sacks last season, demonstrating the kind of interior production that can make Pittsburgh's defense extremely difficult to prepare for. He simply needs to recognize when that aggression is appropriate.
There is also something particularly interesting about the contrasting trajectories of Benton and Black. Pittsburgh invested the 49th overall selection in Benton in 2023, while Black was still available when the organization selected him 164th overall in 2025.
Black is already listed as Pittsburgh's starting nose tackle, and Harrison's film breakdown provided additional evidence of why the coaching staff has trusted him with that responsibility.
Benton has too much talent to become somebody his linebackers have to account for alongside the opposing offensive linemen. Pittsburgh's defensive success depends on him becoming more dependable, even if that means sacrificing an occasional opportunity to chase the quarterback.
Harrison essentially spent Monday explaining why Black's willingness to do the dirty work makes everybody around him better. Benton has the physical ability to provide that same luxury, but Pittsburgh needs to see it more consistently.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

