The Pittsburgh Steelers spent a considerable portion of the offseason rebuilding a secondary that had become increasingly difficult to trust against quality quarterbacks. General Manager Omar Khan brought in several experienced defensive backs, giving Pittsburgh a group that looked significantly better on paper. Unfortunately, two of the Steelers' most important divisional road games have exposed some familiar weaknesses. With another challenging road matchup approaching against the Philadelphia Eagles, one of Pittsburgh's offseason additions is receiving some criticism for his performances when the stakes have been particularly high.

Jordan Schofield / SteelerNation (X: @JSKO_PHOTO)
Pittsburgh Steelers safety Jaquan Brisker (3) during 2026 training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe, PA.
Reporter Ray Fittipaldo appeared on 93.7 The Fan Wednesday morning and evaluated the performance of safety Jaquan Brisker through nine games. While the veteran has enjoyed some encouraging moments during his first season with the Steelers, Fittipaldo believes consistency remains an issue.
“Brisker, I would say he's been up and down. I think he's had good games and bad games,” Fittipaldo said.
Brisker signed a one-year contract with Pittsburgh in March after spending four seasons with the Chicago Bears. The Pittsburgh-area native started all 52 games he appeared in during his time in Chicago, giving the Steelers another experienced player capable of handling multiple responsibilities within their secondary.
Fittipaldo specifically pointed toward Pittsburgh's divisional matchups against the Cleveland Browns and Cincinnati Bengals when discussing his concerns about Brisker.
“It's unfortunate for the Steelers when they have these big division games on the road and their best players don't play well. And I'm not saying Brisker is one of their best players, but I remember Brisker did not play well against the Browns. Like I said, I don't think anyone played well against the Bengals. Certainly no one in the secondary,” Fittipaldo said.
Interestingly, Brisker recorded a season-high 10 tackles during Sunday's 38-18 loss to Cincinnati. However, compiling tackles as a safety isn't necessarily an indication that things are going particularly well defensively.
Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow threw for 409 yards and four touchdowns, with Ja'Marr Chase accounting for 231 receiving yards. Brisker spent much of the evening playing behind a defensive front that managed to sack Burrow just once.
Pittsburgh experienced similar frustrations during its 27-24 loss in Cleveland on October 1. Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson threw for 268 yards and completed four passes for 45 yards on the possession that produced Cleveland's game-winning field goal.

Kirby Lee / Imagn Images
Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow (9) with wide receiver Ja'Marr Chase (1) on the field after defeating the Atlanta Falcons at Bernabeu Stadium.
The circumstances surrounding Brisker haven't exactly been ideal. Veteran safety DeShon Elliott missed the first six games of the season before suffering another knee injury during pregame warmups in Cincinnati. Rookie Robert Spears-Jennings has consequently been asked to handle considerably more responsibility than Pittsburgh probably anticipated when selecting him in the seventh round.
Brisker has been one of the few constants throughout those personnel changes. He has appeared in all nine games, recording 61 tackles, three passes defensed and one interception.
The veteran also discussed Pittsburgh's improved defensive communication before the second meeting against Cleveland. The Steelers appeared to have simplified some of their responsibilities, allowing defenders to play faster and trust one another. Pittsburgh subsequently held the Browns to six points.
Unfortunately, Cincinnati made that improvement look rather temporary.
Defensive Coordinator Patrick Graham needs to find ways to prevent opposing offenses from putting his safeties in increasingly difficult situations. Cincinnati's use of additional blockers gave Burrow time to extend plays, forcing Pittsburgh's defensive backs to maintain coverage well beyond the original timing of passing concepts.
Even excellent safeties have an expiration date when quarterbacks are given that much time to find somebody downfield.
Steelers Need More From Brisker During Their Toughest Matchups
Fittipaldo's criticism doesn't mean Pittsburgh should suddenly consider removing Brisker from the starting lineup. However, the veteran needs to provide more than dependable attendance if the Steelers intend to become a legitimate postseason threat.
The one-year nature of Brisker's contract makes the remainder of the season particularly interesting. Pittsburgh has eight games remaining to determine whether the veteran should become a long-term piece of its secondary or whether the organization needs to revisit the position during the offseason.
The Steelers travel to Philadelphia on Sunday, where they haven't won since 1965. All three of Pittsburgh's losses this season have come on the road, and the possibility of having to win away from Acrisure Stadium in January becomes increasingly realistic with Cincinnati controlling the AFC North.
Brisker has been productive enough to justify Pittsburgh's offseason investment, but Fittipaldo raises a fair question about when that production is occurring. The Steelers need their experienced defensive backs making plays that end possessions, especially when their pass rush isn't making life easy for them.
Pittsburgh already knows Brisker can accumulate tackles. The next eight games should provide a better indication of whether he can consistently prevent the completions that require him to make so many of them.
#SteelerNation
SteelerNation in your inbox
The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.

