Steelers Told To Reject Justin Herbert And Jalen Hurts In 2027 (Steelers News)
Steelers News

Steelers Told To Reject Justin Herbert And Jalen Hurts In 2027

James Lang / Imagn Images
author image

Get every Steelers story first: download the free SteelerNation app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Pittsburgh Steelers are approaching another offseason in which the biggest question surrounding the organization will involve the quarterback position. With Aaron Rodgers intending to retire following the 2026 season, Pittsburgh could finally hand its offense to one of the younger passers it has spent time developing. However, the possibility of several established quarterbacks becoming available next offseason has created an interesting debate. One longtime Steelers insider apparently wouldn't be particularly excited about acquiring some of the biggest names being floated around.

Steelers Sam Darnold

© Mark J. Rebilas / Imagn Images

Seahawks' Sam Darnold celebrates after winning Super Bowl LX.

Steelers insider Mark Kaboly discussed several hypothetical quarterback acquisitions during a recent appearance on 93.7 The Fan. Among the possibilities presented to Kaboly was Seattle Seahawks quarterback Sam Darnold, an idea he dismissed almost immediately.

Kaboly was considerably more receptive when asked about Baltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson, although even acquiring the two-time NFL MVP didn't generate overwhelming enthusiasm.

“I mean, I like it. I wouldn't say I would want it, but it's in between hate it and like it,” Kaboly said.

The conversation became particularly interesting when two other accomplished quarterbacks were brought up. Kaboly responded with a simple “Hate it” when asked about acquiring Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts. His reaction to the possibility of bringing Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert to Pittsburgh was even stronger.

“Hate it. Don't even mention it. Terrible,” Kaboly said.

That is a fairly remarkable collection of quarterbacks to dismiss, considering what Steelers fans have watched at the position over the past several seasons. Hurts has won a Super Bowl, Herbert possesses one of the most impressive throwing arms in professional football, and Darnold has successfully resurrected a career that once appeared destined for permanent backup duty.

However, acquiring any of those players would involve considerably more than convincing them to put on a Steelers uniform.

Darnold signed a three-year, $100.5 million contract with Seattle in 2025. Hurts and Herbert are both playing on extensions worth more than $250 million. All three remain under contract beyond the current season, meaning Pittsburgh would likely have to sacrifice valuable draft capital in addition to taking on significant financial commitments.

Jackson's situation might be the most fascinating of the group. The veteran is recovering from surgery on his throwing thumb and carries a projected salary cap charge of $84.34 million for 2027. Baltimore has yet to secure another extension with its franchise quarterback, whose current agreement runs through next season.

Of course, the Ravens voluntarily sending Jackson to Pittsburgh would rank among the strangest decisions in the history of professional football. His contract also contains a no-trade clause, adding another layer of complexity to an already unlikely scenario.

Steelers' Lamar Jackson

Ravens YouTube Channel

Ravens' Lamar Jackson speaks to members of the Baltimore media.

Kaboly's reluctance to embrace those possibilities becomes more understandable when considering his recent comments about rookie quarterback Drew Allar. The insider has repeatedly expressed confidence that Allar will receive a legitimate opportunity to start for Pittsburgh next season.

Head Coach Mike McCarthy and General Manager Omar Khan selected Allar 76th overall in April. Pittsburgh also retained second-year quarterback Will Howard, giving the organization two relatively inexpensive developmental options.

Discovering that one of those players can become a legitimate NFL starter would allow Pittsburgh to continue investing heavily elsewhere on its roster. Finding that same answer through a blockbuster acquisition would likely require the organization to make considerable sacrifices.

Still, there's a difference between avoiding another temporary quarterback solution and completely dismissing the possibility of acquiring an established franchise player.


Steelers Shouldn't Immediately Dismiss A Potential Justin Herbert Trade

Pittsburgh should absolutely give Allar and Howard opportunities to compete for the starting job. However, treating Herbert like another aging veteran looking for a temporary home seems unnecessarily dismissive.

Herbert is only 28 years old. Despite the Chargers' difficulties, his physical ability and extensive starting experience make him considerably different from the veteran quarterbacks Pittsburgh has pursued in recent years. If Los Angeles ever became willing to discuss a trade, Khan would be doing the organization a disservice by refusing to explore the possibility.

The same principle applies to Jackson, although the divisional circumstances make that scenario significantly less realistic.

Pittsburgh doesn't need another quarterback whose primary purpose is keeping the organization respectable for one season. It needs somebody capable of giving the Steelers a legitimate championship window.

That quarterback could already be inside the building. However, if an opportunity to acquire somebody like Herbert actually materializes, Pittsburgh shouldn't let its determination to develop a franchise quarterback prevent it from acquiring one.


#SteelerNation

SteelerNation in your inbox

The biggest Steelers stories, free, straight to your email.